| Author |
Message |
Oregonguy
Member
02-12-2006
| Wednesday, September 15, 2010 - 8:11 pm 
Annual ranking of winners
1. Will (BB2) best ever
2. Maggie (BB6) most unappreciated winner
3. Boogie (BB7) amazing chilltown made it to the end
4. Dan (BB10)
5. Jordan (BB11)
6. Hayden (BB12)
7. Drew (BB5)
8. Lisa (BB3)
9. Jun (BB4)
10. Adam (BB9)
11. Dick (BB8) disgusts me to even write his name
12. Eddie (BB1) didnt watch his season
WHATS YOUR LIST
|
Sparkle
Member
08-24-2007
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 7:57 am
1. Will best ever
2. Dan
3. Eddie
4. Boogie(still feel Will won it for him)
5. Dick
6. Jun
7. Maggie (though I didn't care for her)
8. Jordan
9. Drew
10. Lisa
11. Hayden
12. Adam
|
Jimmer
Moderator
08-30-2000
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 8:47 am
Perhaps it would be interesting if each person states the criteria they are using for ranking (e.g. best game player, most entertaining, most likable, etc.)? Because I think my rankings would change based on the criteria used.
|
Caprica
Member
02-10-2007
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 9:07 am
1. Dan(played an awesome social game and won comps when he needed.)
2. Maggie(controlled her alliance like a cult leader.)
3. Jun(made flaoting work and her alliance with Allison sealed the deal.)
4. Drew(rode the 4 horsemen for as long as he could and the dumped them to save himself.)
5. Hayden(Used his alliance too his advantage.)
6. Boogie(Will cared him to the end but he did the work in the final 3.)
7. Adam(goofed off until everyone else was gone.)
8. Jordan(played nice and was pawned to the end.)
9. Dick (Entire season was rigged for him. Eric said he would have lobbied for Dick to go week two had he not been doing Americas bidding.)
Will and Lisa both won during seasons where the jury was not sequestered. I do not want to diminish their wins but can not rank them with the others.If the juries had not seen the DR's there is no way of knowing what the out come would have been.
Eddie was picked by America no gaming involved.
This list has absolutely nothing to do with who I like. It's all about game play.
|
Kittystj
Member
08-10-2001
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 3:09 pm
Don't know all the winners BUT my favorite
player will for ever be Curtis, from BB1.
|
Idolworship
Member
05-07-2003
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 3:42 pm
I like Oregonguy's list, and I did watch the first season. 'Not fond of Eddie. I wanted Curtis to win.
Looking at the list, again, I'd move Maggie and (ugh) "Boogie" down the list, to just above Evil Dick. (I also want to wretch, just printing his name.)
|
Bicbicz911
Member
08-19-2005
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 4:58 pm
1. Will
2. Dick
3. Eddie
4. Dan
5. Jun
6. Drew
7. Jordan
8. Maggie
9. Adam
10. Hayden
11. Mike Boogie
|
Saguaro
Member
06-21-2005
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 5:16 pm
My criteria is who I was most happy about them winning.
1. Will
2. Dick
3. Boogie
4. Maggie
5. Jordan
6. Lisa
7. Hayden
8. Drew
9. Dan
10. Eddie
11. Adam
12. Jun
|
Bicbicz911
Member
08-19-2005
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 5:45 pm
Oops, forgot Lisa. And she makes the 12th spot, since she was the worst (IMO).
|
Bbwatcher
Member
09-12-2008
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 6:02 pm
1) Will
2) Jordan
3) Eddie
4) Dan
5) Dick
6) Drew
7) Hayden
8) Lisa
9) Boogie
10) Maggie
11) Jun
12) Adam
|
Archiecat
Member
08-16-2006
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 6:10 pm
My ranking would be colored by whose social game I was happy about. I know, that is prejudicial, but as mentioned above, some of them made me want to throw up...therefore I cannot list them as "best."....so:
Will
Dan
Jordan
Drew
Boogie
Jun
Lisa
Hayden
Eddie
Maggie
Dick
Didn't watch season 9 at all because of Dick in Season 8, so I can't rank Adam (he would probably come before Dick, though)
|
Triciatoronto
Member
07-04-2010
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 6:35 pm
I am basing my list on who I liked best. Not necessarily their game play but them.
1) Dan
2) Will
3) Jordan
4) Lisa
5) Eddie
6) Hayden
7) Drew
8) Boogie
9) Jun
10) Adam
11) Maggie
12) Dick
|
Scubalass
Member
07-01-2004
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 6:45 pm
1. Will
2. Dick
3. Dan
4. Maggie
5. Mike Boogie
6. Jun
7. Drew
8. Hayden
9. Jordan
10. Lisa
11. Eddie
12. Adam
Based this on what I regard as gameplay not the order that I liked them
|
Matteroftime
Member
09-04-2010
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 7:49 pm
Going by game play:
1. Will - The best evah!!
2. Evel Dick
3. Dan
4. Maggie
5. Boogie
6. Hayden
7. Lisa
8. Eddie
9. Drew
10.Jun
11.Jordan
12.Adam
|
Alliet
Member
07-11-2005
| Thursday, September 16, 2010 - 10:05 pm
S1 was the only year a person I wanted to win actually did win.
|
Darclyte
Member
07-11-2005
| Friday, September 17, 2010 - 6:47 am
Overall gameplay
Dan
Evel Dick
Evil Dr Will
Hayden
Maggie
Drew
Mike Boogie
Jordan
Lisa
Eddie
Adam
Jun
|
Texasdeb
Member
05-23-2003
| Friday, September 17, 2010 - 11:58 am
my choices are based on how I liked them on their season and how much I felt they deserved the win on their season:
1) Dan
2) Dick
3) Will
4) jun
5) Boogie
6) Drew
7) Hayden
8) Jordan
9) Adam
10) Lisa
11) Eddie
12) Maggie
|
Merrysea
Moderator
08-13-2004
| Friday, September 17, 2010 - 12:48 pm
Texasdeb, I like your list. I can't ever give credit to Maggie for her gameplay because she refused to own it. In the diary room, she was always so shocked that people thought she was controlling the game. I think she was just a controlling person, so she doesn't deserve credit for it.
|
Chippy
Member
08-16-2007
| Saturday, September 18, 2010 - 10:38 am
Feh. I can't really put them in any order. I can say that I've yet to watch a season (and have watched every one of them) that I thought the best player won. I've seen them in the finals but they've come in second. I guess Dan and Will were the closest- for me anyways. Plus, I tend to avoid looking back since each season is so different in terms of personalities on board. What works for one season wouldn't stand up in another. There just wasn't any standouts this season. HoHum blah. There was potential but it left so early that we never got to see it. Reminded me of a semi-comatose Maggie season.
|
