Archive through October 07, 2002
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

TV ClubHouse: Archives: Rank the Survivors in the Order that You Like Them: Archive through October 07, 2002

Muse

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 08:15 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
It's a tradition around here, isn't it? :)

My picks:

1) Brian - Seems to be fair, kind, and reasonable. I also think he might end up being a very savvy player.
2) Ken - Ditto. I like how he based his vote on who didn't contribute to the tribe, rather than petty personal differences.
3) Shii Ann - Smart, funny, sarcastic. Hates Robb, which wins her extra points.
4) Jake - Seems like a natural leader who isn't overly bossy. It sounds like he has an alliance with Shii Ann, which I like.
5) Clay - Seems nice enough. I liked his comments about Ghandia's temper tantrum.
6) Ted - I think he and Ghandia both got a little too touchy-feely, but I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt about the whole sexual stuff, largely because of the way he handled it afterward.
7) Erin/Penny - Haven't really gotten to know either one yet.
8) Jan - Cries too much, seems pretty weak physically. She probably means well, though.
9) Stephanie - Seems to have a negative attitude.
10) Helen - Seems like a bit of a snake, and I don't mean that in the Richard Hatch sort of way. I don't like how she told Brian how he was supposed to vote, how she sided with Ghandia without even bothering to talk to Ted, or how rigid/stern she seems.
11) Ghandia - Overemotional drama queen. No self-control. She handled the Ted situation poorly, regardless of whether he did something wrong or not.
12) Robb - ANNOYING. Go home, Robb.

Jasonfan

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 08:46 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I'm with you, Muse, on 1, 2, 3 and 12. I'm not sure about the others yet.

I can understand Jeff's comment about the "grade-five like behaviour" of these contestants.

Azriel

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 08:58 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1.Brian - I really really like him and hope I'm not giving him the kiss of death by doing so.

2.Clay - down home, real person I'm rooting for him.

3.Ted - I believe his version of events re: Ghandia I think she made a mountain out of a molehill. I think Ted will help my guys Brian and Clay so I'm rooting for him too

4.Shii Ann - You have to like anyone that irritates Robb

5.Jan - I like her spirit. She's trying hard and not complaining about the hardships. I think she is an asset to her team.

I don't think I like anyone else enough to put them on a list.

I don't know why so many people like Jake and Ken. They watch their team running amok and don't have the balls to stand up and get them in shape.

Erin and Penny are non entities. We hear how lazy Jed was but other than getting together a few fronds and throwing them on top of the shelter I haven't seen them do much but walk around and look pathetic and hungry.

Helen and Ghandia are trouble makers. I don't like thier attitudes.

I'm kind of ho-hum about Stephanie. I think it's funny that she refuses to sleep in their shelter. I'm not sure I'd sleep in it after all the crap that was stirred making it.

Robb, Dude, your village is missing it's idiot, please go home.

Lombadier

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 09:02 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Brian
2. Clay - I also loved his comment about Ghandia's tantrum tonight.
3. Shi Ann
4. Jake

Too early to really like any of the others yet. I did like Ted, I still do (and thought he was great during the reward challenge tonight) but the whole thing with Ghandia really disappointed me.

Hermione69

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 09:36 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I hated Clay's comment. I must be in the minority. For one thing, if Ghandia had not screamed and called attention to herself like that first, the shadowboxing and stone throwing is not a bad way to work through anger. Now, we don't need to get in whether it was justified anger or not, it was there and she had to deal with it. I also didn't like "when my two year old behaves like that, I whip its ass and send it back to bed." I didn't like his referring to his child as an it or the ass-whipping comment. It just didn't sit well with me.

Notice I said, I hated his comment, not him... I like the whole tribe, with Brian and Jan on top of my list. As far as Sook Jai, I'm not sure. Ken is terribly easy on my eyes. Erin and Penny seem pretty likable. Shii Ann is feisty, in a good way, I think. I just don't really like them as a group. I'm kind of looking forward to a mixup because I think it reveals a lot more about people's personalities.

Sisalou

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 09:45 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Azriel - ROFLMAO - "Robb, Dude, your village is missing it's idiot, please go home."

260

Rosa

Thursday, October 03, 2002 - 10:35 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1Robb-bad survivor editing,good looking, hard worker. 2Jake- Seems like a good team player.3Helen-capable,smart.4Brian- cute , great team player. 5Clay- cute in a Woody Allen sort of way, good team player.6-9Erin, Penny, Jan, Stepanie-no real opinion ,need to see more tv air time.10-NYPD cop, forgot his name but though he seems like a great guy I do not want him to get a free pass because of 9/11. 11-Ghandia -I still like her but she made a big mistake not dropping the whole Ted thing. 12- Ted, Needs to watch his roving hands, I did not buy his excuses either. 13-Shii Ann- Could she be more self rightous if she tried? I think not. She Devil ohhhh.

Nessietessie

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 05:43 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Brian
2. Ken
3. Clay
4. Ted
5. Penny
6. Erin
7. Jan
8. Shi
9. Jake
10.Helen
11.Robb
12.Stephanie
13.GaWINYdia

Chiparock

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 05:57 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Clay
2. Ken
3. Ted
4. Shii Ann
5. Brian
6. Jake
7. Helen
8. Penny
9. Erin
10. Jan
11. Stephanie
12. Robb
13. Ghandia

Fruitbat

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 06:37 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Orange:

1. Brian- he kept a cool head and operated with integrity.

2. Ted- he and Ghandia engaged in a little harmless touchy feely. He apologized. Good enough for me.

Bottom- Ghandia, Clay and Helen

Clays comment about whooping his two year old queered it for me.

Ghandia- horrible behavior. Devious and mean.

Helen- Gossip. Leaped to Ghandia's side without enought info. Dangerous for team.

Jan- Just don't like her. She irritates me.

Purple-

We haven't seen enough of them yet. I like all with the exception of Robb and Stephanie.

Erin may emerge as a good woman and strong player. Sui Ann already has.

Earthmother

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 06:47 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Ted
Brian
Jan
Ken
Clay
Shi Ann
Everyone else not mentioned in this list
Helen
Robb
Ghandia

Eliz87

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 07:34 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Brian - Seems very nice, reasonable, mature, patient. Hopefully he will prove to be a good strategic game player as well. Certainly nice to look at.

2. Ken - Shares Brian's qualities.

3. Robb - Can't help it. I love watching this guy, for the entertainment value if for nothing else. As I've stated before, he's nice eye candy as well. I also don't care for Shi Ann either, so that's one point for him too. Hopefully he'll "chill out" a bit in the episodes to come.

4. Helen - I like Helen. She is someone I would like to have around in a survival situation, and I don't understand why her fellow tribe members are resenting her for displaying her knowledge about things (i.e. cooking squid). I was very impressed with her with the way she didn't "go off" on Jan while she was doing the "dead man's float" and letting Helen carry the heavy water jugs by herself.

5. Jake - Smart for picking the young, strong players to be in his tribe. The challenges have been quite physical thus far.

6. Clay - Seems very down-to-earth. I too enjoyed his comments about Ghandia's temper tantrum.

7. Ted - He's okay, I THINK. I am kind of having a hard time giving him the benefit of the doubt about the thing with Ghandia (I'd KILL my husband if he "accidentally" grinded with another woman), but I do like the way he handled it the next day by bringing everyone together and getting it out in the open like he did. The jury's still out on my final opinion of Ted.

8. Penny - Does she remind anyone else of Laurie from the Partridge Family? (Or am I thinking about Erin?)

9. Erin - Maybe she's the Susan Dey lookalike. I don't know. Both Penny and Erin have been pretty much nonexistent so far. I think they've been cast as eye candy for the male viewers. Hopefully one of them will surprise us.

10. Jan - I think she's a little bit lazy (I'm thinking back on the "dead man's float" situation with Helen), and I'm sorry, but she really doesn't dress appropriately for her age. I am 32 and I don't let my butt cheeks hang out of my bathing suit. Okay, my butt cheeks are BIG, but STILL, even if they weren't I wouldn't let them hang out all over the place. ;-) She seems nice enough, I suppose, but the way she presents herself distracts me from seeing her personality. The accent gets on my nerves too. (I know this is unfair of me to judge her on her sound and appearance, but I can't help it. She irritates me.)

11. Shi Ann - Annoying. I don't like the way she asks others what she should do (i.e. wandering around asking what to do when the guys were building shelter, asking during the luxury comp whether her teammates wanted her to push the guy off the log). As for her "funny" sarcasm, she should save it until she has proven that she knows how to think for herself. I have to admit, though, it was smart on her part to throw the immunity competition (if this is in fact what she did) to get rid of some dead wood (Jed).

12. Stephanie - Reminds me of Shannon from BB2.

13. Ghandia - I really don't like the way she handled the situation with Ted. IMO, as a married woman, she shouldn't have been snuggling with anyone, period. And she definitely shouldn't have told "the girls" about the situation after she accepted Ted's apology. And the tantrum -- UGH. Too much of a drama queen for me.

Bmh

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 10:22 am EditMoveDeleteIP
FAVORITES

1.Shii Ann~She is the best!..I hope she gets really bitchy next week..and flips out on a few ppl..it would be a riot..I love her narration

2.Ken~really strong in challenges..good asset..is probably 2nd in command..and wont be going anywhere for a while

3.Penny~She is just so cute!..She is always smiling..she is alot like Liz..I hope we hear more from her next week

4.Jake~I really like him..him and Shii would make a great duo..I see him going far..He is really respected at the SJ camp.

5.Ted~my favorite..CG guy..he is a good guy..and his moves on Ghandia were purely accidental..the tribe will side with him

NEUTRAL

6.Brian~this guy is smart..he is working the conflicts at CG to his advantage..and is def. a power in the tribe..he has potential

7.Erin~she is kind of mysterious..She is really cute..and I know she is part of some sort of alliance at SJ bc of her comments about gettin rid of ppl..she could be a critcal player..later on

8.Jan~did not make an impact on me this week..except grossin me out..with that binkin bottom she was wearing..I hope she doesn't turn into Kim J..she needs to find her own strategy in the game..she really isn't so bad..but the pig-tails still need to go..lol

9.Stephanie~she is still a dumbass..for sleepin in the rain when she is already sick..and is now the most vunerable in her tribe..she really could have gone far..but aligning with Robb and Jed is not a smart choice lol..She is screwed..

DISLIKE

10.Clay~this guy is a freak..he aggravates me..i didn't like his comment about hitting his kid..that was un-called for..whether it was a joke or not..i hope he is outta here soon

11.Helen~still annoying..still arrogant and recently figured out she was actually playing a game..no sh*t sherlock..I cant stand her

12.Ghandia~this lady needs to chill..she is blowing everything out of porportion..and it is ruining her chances at doing good at this game..she sickens me

13.Robb~Why in the world is he still here?..please vote him off soon..SJ voted off the wrong person..he is a whiney sore loser..get over it..and stop picking on shii ann!

~Jed would have been in neutral zone..because he was kind of weird..but a good asset to the tribe..and was edited as lazy but wasn't even that bad..he cooked and feed the tribe..while everybody kept building the All Mighty Shelter..he was a good guy..but the game goes on...

Quietstorm4

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 10:41 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Favorites:

1. Brian
2. Shi Ann

Neutral:

3. Ted
4. Clay
5. Jan
6. Penny
7. Ken
8. Jake
9. Erin
10. Stephanie

Dislike:
11. Helen
12. Ghandia
13. Robb

Alaginger

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 11:20 am EditMoveDeleteIP
This is my ranking and reasons as this point. As the game goes on and I see and learn more, I'm apt to change my mind....but that is a woman's perogative .... right?

Ken (I liked his train of thought when he responded to Robb trying to get him to vote out Shi Ann, plus he has done his share, stayed under the radar, and not created any problems with anybody)
Brian (Seems a good teammate...and a clear head)
Jake (Good Sport)
Shi (Very Competitive)
Clay (Good Ole Guy From my State)
Helen (Hard worker)
Jan (Great in competitions of swimming and puzzles)
Ted (Lots of muscle power)
Penny (Don't know enough about...but better than
Stephanie, Ghandia, or Robb)
Erin (Same as Penny)
Stephanie (Lazy and standoffish)
Ghandia (troublemaker)
Robb (sickening)

Monkeyboy

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 05:53 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
hey azriel, im from that idiots village! we dont want him back!

shii ann is the arizona survivor that im rooting for.

Adrian

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 09:20 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Shi Ann
2. Ken
3. Brian

4-12 ?

13. Robb

Cervesa

Saturday, October 05, 2002 - 09:58 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Shi Ann (you go girl!)
2. Brian (who knew??)
3. Ken (I'd probably like him a lot more if he got any real screen time)
4. Jake
5. Helen (she's growing on me)
6. Jan
7. Ted (he seems genuine to me)
8. Penny (don't know enough about her)
9. Clay (i liked him a lot more before he referred to his 2 year old as "it")
10. Erin
11. Ghandia (please go away)
12.Stephanie (lazy and annoying)
13.Robb (this guy's stupidity is baffling)

Monkeyboy

Sunday, October 06, 2002 - 08:17 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1.Shii Ann (funny and competetive)
2.Brian (seems like a respectible guy)
3.Jan (seems like a sweetheart)
4.Helen (seems like a strong woman)
5.Clay (nice guy)
6.Jake (reminds me of my grandpa )
7,8,9,10. Erin, Ken, Penny, Stephanie (ZZZZZZ)
11,12.Ghandia, Ted (gag, go away from my TV!)
13.Robb (double gag, we can only hope a coconut falls on his head and that they have to send him away!)

Jagger

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 11:23 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Brian
Robb
Helen
Rest I really don't know
Ghei...
Shi ann

Mygetaway

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 12:25 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I haven't really seen enough of Sook Jai to judge them yet, but here goes....

I like Shi Ann.
Probably will like Ken and Penny.
Tides still out on Erin, hopefully she's nothing like Sara.
Stephanie? I think she's hurting herself by going off on her own. I liked her by her bio, but don't know now.
Jake??
Robb... he bugs me but I don't "hate" him.

As for the others over at Chuay....

I like Brian so far.
I kind of like Clay as the little guy "underdog."
Jan bugs me.
Helen is a strong woman, and I'm neutral on her so far.
Ted is losing ground fast and probably doesn't have a chance.
I don't like Ghandia. I didn't really like her from the beginning. I'm glad she has no self image problems, but it bugged me the way she thought she was "all that." I wouldn't want to see her win.

Tabbyking

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 01:05 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
clay's children are 17 and 23. he does not currently have a 2-year-old. his comment to ghandia made sense to me. i mean, you don't beat a kid, but one whoop on the bottom and that gets their attention. i don't think he was advocating child abuse. i think he meant she was acting like a 2-year-old and needed one good swat on the tush.
we had an expert come speak to the parents and teachers several years ago in our elementary schools and someone asked about spanking (by a parent, not a teacher)...and his talk included 'one swat on the behind' to get the kid's attention, when they are acting out of control or having a screaming fit. sometimes it's like 'turning off the switch' when they are on a roll and in a full-blown tantrum.
anyway, i didn't take clay to mean to beat the crap out of a small, defenseless child.(unlike that woman who should be shot for beating her daughter in the SUV)... he is not my favorite, but he is near the top.
so far, i like more of the men than the women contestants. brian, jake, ken, clay...
for the women, uh....penny seems okay, but we sure haven't seen her much. i really wanted to like helen--near my age, i guess!--but instead of ragging about jan behind her back, she should have asked for her help during the water search. she also spread ghandia's story around. so i don't much care for her now.

i like pappy! oh, wrong cast. well, ethan then. oh my heck, that survivor show's done, too? i guess the only person i like pretty much and he's guaranteed to not get booted is jeff probst. perfect name, too...the 'probster', who asks all the probing questions at tribal council.

Essence

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 01:31 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Brian, Ted, and Shi Ann in no particular order. (I think Ted had some fault, but he handled the situation well...so did Brian).

I'm neutral about Clay and Jan.

I don't know enough yet about Stephanie, Penny, Erin, and Ken.

I just flat out don't like Robb, Helen, Ghandia, and Jake (there's something about Jake that just rubs me the wrong way).

Betty

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 01:32 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
In no particular order, I like Chewing Gum with the exception of Ghandia. Now at Sukiyaki, well lets just say I wouldn't be too disappointed if they got abucted by little green men. Oh, make it easy and just switch Ghandia with ShuiAnn.


Snicker, snicker. Just thinking about Ghandia's head exploding if Clay laid his hand to her rump.

Cas

Monday, October 07, 2002 - 03:59 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I don´t have a feel for half of them but who I´d like to see make the merge.

ShiiAnn
Ken
Penny
Erin
Clay
Brian
Ted
Jan or Jake(just because I need eight right? Don´t really care for either of them at this point)

I dislike Ghandia, Helen, Robb and Stephanie.