Ok lurkers and nonlurkers come out of hiding and tell us who you like so far. Don't be shy.
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

TV ClubHouse: Archives: Ok lurkers and nonlurkers come out of hiding and tell us who you like so far. Don't be shy.
 SubtopicMsgs  Last Updated
Archive through September 25, 2002 25   09/25 02:21pm
Archive through September 27, 2002 25   09/27 09:41pm

Shanfan

Friday, September 27, 2002 - 11:02 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
**lurker peeking around corner**

I don't like Helen's reasoning for voting against Clay in week 1. "Not needing the money" is lame-o, especially since Ghandia blew the entire challenge for the tribe.

Rooting for Jake. He grew up where I now live.

I don't find Robb to likeable personality wise, but he's not too bad to look at.

Lfprsrule

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 05:49 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I've been glued to the BB FLPs for three years but this is my first time in Survivor area - Hi all :)
(btw, love Fruitbat & Seamonkey posts - crak me up!)

I hope Helen survives - she is kinda bossy but I think a good player (except for comment above about Clay-who cares if he has money!)

Don't like Robb either - reminds me of a 12 year old!

Hermione69

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 07:41 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Changes in opinion after episode 2-

I like most of the people on Chuay Gahn. Ghandia did alienate me a bit with her snooty comment about Helen at TC, especially coming after her poor performance in the 1st IC. I've started to really root for Jan, in part because so many people here don't like her and my underdog sympathies are kicking into gear. Also in part because it takes a special person to be an elementary school teacher. That is not an easy job and most people I know who spend their lives as one are kind, giving, and big-hearted people. (As for the water jug issue-- I think there was more there than what MB showed... currently not a valid reason to dislike her IMHO)

On Sook Jai, I don't feel like I have gotten to know them much. I get positive impressions from Erin and Penny. They both seem good-natured and cheerful. Pretty neutral on the others, even Robb who seemed so obnoxious on ep. 1. I don't want to start jumping on Jed and Stephanie just yet until I see a bit more of them, but they certainly came across as slackers in ep. 2.

Nessietessie

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 08:50 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Like:
1.Brian (seems kind, and is eye candy)
2.Ted (I love the way he acts)
3.Clay (don't know why, but I do)
4.Helen( didn't talk about Jan)

Do not like:
1. Stephanie (going skinny dipping
in front of others you just met,
seems strange, especially when nobody
else did it. Also sleeping away
from everyone shows she is not a
team player.)
2. Jed (looks like a slacker.)
3. Ghandia (seems way too emotional.)
4. Jan (too emotional.)
5. Shi Ann (got in argument with Robb)

Love him and hate him:
1. Robb

Who are they! Haven't seen them much:
1. Ken
2. Penny
3. Erin
4. Jake

Ophiliasgrandma

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 09:13 am EditMoveDeleteIP
It's too soon for me to make a judgement as I can't get my brain around so many contestants. As they get tossed one by one I'll be better able to make a decision. Although, some of the lesser personalities are beginning to show already. It's pretty hard for the unlikeables to hide their less endearing qualities under the proverbial bushel basket to too long. They do quickly seem to float to the top and get skimmed off fast.

Bbfanatic

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 10:37 am EditMoveDeleteIP
i am obviously an oddball here. while watching the first show, i could tell mb was really trying hard to make one tribe look like a bunch of slackers & the other soooo mature. he really was emphasizing Robb as being someone that could possibly be booted at the end of the show if that side had to go to tribal council. so i overlooked robb being an energetic goofball on the first show for that reason. he did look like a hard worker. i figured it was just edited that way. in the second show he was made to look like he was lazy. maybe it was just a break. he does look like a great competitor in competitions. i like his energy, enthusiasm, & competitive sides. as long as they are not used in a negative way in the future they can be an advantage. so, as you can tell, i am giving him the benefit of the doubt for now. i would just rather listen to him than listen to ghandia or shi ann complain. the porn guy creeps me out ?? dont know why. so i will take robb for now.

Marymc

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 04:11 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
robb creeps me out.

shii ann kicks a$$.

brian is skeevy-smarmy. a porn-star turned used car salesman? geeeez! interesting career choices....

jed, i could look at all day, but that's about it.

skinny-dipper girl never read the book "how to win friends and influence people".

Jaxrock

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 05:14 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
First time poster on Survivor, I'm usually in BB-land,
I don't really have a favorite, except maybe Ted, but I do know who I don't like (which means he'll probably win) and that is Robb (sp?). Just something about him on the first show that makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up.

Chiparock

Saturday, September 28, 2002 - 05:48 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
SMARMY!! Yes, that's Brian, Marymc! "It's all about love"? Give me a break. Gaaggggg.

Goooooooo, Clay!

Alinthehouse

Sunday, September 29, 2002 - 10:57 am EditMoveDeleteIP
It’s too early in the game for me to decide who I want to win, but....

I liked Jed on the first episode, then things changed. He seems to give his all on the challenges. I was disappointed on the last episode. He was not doing his part in helping the tribe. You cannot, in my opinion, sit around and not do any work. He will be singled out quick. All in all, he’s easy on the eyes!!!

Robb drives me crazy. I wanted to yell at the tv and tell him to fix his beanie. It was over his eyes. Hurt my neck just watching him try to see from under it! He appears to think he’s all that. Skateboard on the sand...hum. I don’t want to pass judgment so early in the game, but he’s got to go.

(back to lurking!)

Lycanthrope

Sunday, September 29, 2002 - 10:39 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Okay, after 2nd ep. I've changed my mind on some folks:

Jed- Moody, lazy, loners don't make it far in this game: 2

Jake- Strong player, works hard: 8

Ken- Strong player, works hard, and I like his diaries: 9

Robb- Potentially strong player, works hard, not as bad as myself and many others originally thought: 6

Penny- Works hard, under radar??: 7

Erin- Works hard, seems likable: 8

Stephanie- Not a lot upstairs so far, loner-ish: 3

Shii Ann- Feisty, works hard, intelligent: 9

Ted- Strong player, likable: 9

Brian- Nice guy, potentially strong player: 9

Clay- Likable guy, could form a powerful alliance with Ted and Brian: 9

Jan- Whiny and weak, but a nice lady: 5

Helen- Strong, but may not be the best player, probably needs an alliance to go much past the merge: 7

Ghandia- Doesn't seem very smart; for a married woman, she's very handsy with Big Ted: 2

John- Opinion hasn't changed of course. Made the classic Survivor mistake of assuming leadership: 2

Tanya- Physically weak, couldn't eat the food they caught, otherwise a treat to watch: 7

Ken, Penny, Robb, Helen, and Erin all went up in my view, while Jed and Stephanie took a nosedive. I haven't liked Ghandia from the beginning and still don't.

Alliance potential:

The "Chewy's" could form a S1 type alliance between Ted, Clay, Brian, and Helen. It would be strong and powerful and could get them to the final 4. The problem is Clay doesn't care for Helen much so far.

The "Sookies" have several alliance potentials. Jake could probably pick his 3 or 4 favorites and form a pretty strong alliance. I'd bet on Ken, Robb, Penny, and Erin as targets of his, but if he was smart he'd take Shii Ann because of her intelligence. I don't see the younger ones turning on him at all. They really need him. Bottom line is that they need to become a team quickly and bond as such. I wouldn't be surprised if they threw an IC just to cut the fat(Jed and Stephanie).

Joyful

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 11:54 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I like the < Chewy tribe > because I always pull for the underdog. As for favorite survivors, I'm not real sure yet but I do like Ted and Brian. Brian certainly does seem to be intelligent for a Porn star. Ghandia whines too much for me, tho I did like her at first.

Ginger1218

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 12:43 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Ted and Brian too. Isnt Brian the Used car Salesman? I like this tribe better than the other. I absolutely cannot stand Robb, I want him to be eaten by a big animal. LOL

Denecee

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 01:09 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Brian because he plays the guitar and he seems very nice at this point in the game. I haven't got all the names/faces straight yet so I'll have to answer this one later with more detail. Can't wait till Thursday!

Ladytex

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 01:46 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Ted and Ken. For some reason, I like the Shi-Devil, too. Brian kinda creeps me out. I used to like Jed, but this last episode made him look lazy (I really hope he is not like that). The editing in this show is gonna drive me bonkers. They can make these people look any way they want them to (guess I got spoiled watching feeds).

Rosa

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 01:54 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Rob- recognize editing for him but find he is a hard worker- eye candy. Like Helen- feel sorry for her to be in that tribe. Do not like Shii ann, gave herself nickname(she devil) find her to be very annoying and a nag. Ken- of course he seems like all American hero type but hope voting is not swayed because he is NYC cop. Porno guy- give him a break, he seems ok. Erin- hope voting is not swayed on her looks alone. Clay- I'm in love. John- Good ridence, just what they need, someone trying to "save" them when they are looking for water. Jedd- needs to pitch in and help.Ghandia- delusional, should have brought mirror to island if she thinks Ted is after her. haven't formed any opinion about the rest.

Alaginger

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 05:47 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Sook Jai - Favorites: Ken(10),Jake(9),Shi Ann(8)
No Opinion Yet: Erin, Penny
Don't Like: Robb(1),Stephanie(2),Jed(3)

Chuay Gahn - Favorites: Brian(10),Ted(9)
Helen(8),Clay(7),Jan(7)
Don't Like: Ghandia

Riviere

Monday, September 30, 2002 - 10:25 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I liked the Chewing Gum tribe from the getgo but they shoot themselves in the foot over & over.. I think the weakest should go first but they get rid of 'personality' instead.. Hey Jan, honey, you're going to rue the day you didn't pick Ken over the pastor.. All downhill from here..

Lycanthrope

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 12:42 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Okay, after 3rd ep...

Jake- Part of the strong 5 on the Sookies, in a position of power: 8

Ken- Ditto Jake, but with a better personality: 9

Shii Ann- Smart, sly, and still my favorite: 10

Erin- Aligned with right group, eye candy: 8

Penny- Sweet, allianced up to make the merge: 8

Robb- Competitor, but priorities and mouth will do him in: 6

Stephanie- Loner. Alienated from group: 5

Jed- Lazy loner, good riddance: 1

Ted- Will prove to be good guy and strong player in long run, methinks: 8

Brian- Now the strongest, most likable player in the game: 10

Helen- Taking Ghandia's side in the "He said, she said" battle will be her undoing: 6

Jan- Invisible in ep. 3. Less vocal about support of Ghandia, probably realizes Ted is on the level, and a good guy: 7

Ghandia- Still don't like her, never have, she needs to go: 1

John- Already forgotten: 1

Tanya- Still cute. My mom would love it if I dated a girl like her(so would I): 7

Need to leave: Stephanie and Ghandia
Sentimental favorite: Shii Ann
Strategy favorite: Brian
Cutest girl: Erin
Coolest guy: Ken

Chewy's are split down the middle right now, but Jan is the wildcard. I predict the next one gone from this tribe will be Ghandia. My potential alliance of Ted, Brian, Clay, and Helen has changed to Ted, Brian, Clay, and Jan.

Sookies are more clearcut at 5-2. I correctly predicted the throwing of the IC to get the outcasts booted in ep. 3, and that could happen again. Jake, Shii Ann, and Erin seem to not care for Steph and Robb too much. I think the next one gone from this tribe will be Steph. I'm happy that Shii Ann is in the strong alliance instead of Robb.

Catch ya next episode...

Harkonnen

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 12:58 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Chuay Ghan: Favorite-Brian. Can't stand-Ghandia. Sook Jai: Favorite-Shii Ann. Can't stand-Robb.

Silksmoke

Friday, October 04, 2002 - 02:43 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
what Harkonnen said on the "can't stands"

On Chuay Ghan: I like Brian, Clay and Ted (Ghandia only wishes. She used Ted for her little melodrama)

On Sook Jai: I like Ken

Bluie

Friday, October 11, 2002 - 10:48 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Chewy I like : Helen, Brian, Clay, Jan
Sook Jai I like : Jake, Ken

Can't stand : Ghandia, Ted, Robb, Jed, Sook Jai as a group

For entertainment value I like : Robb, Clay, Jeff Probst

Risa

Friday, October 11, 2002 - 11:07 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I only really like 3 players-Robb, Helen, and Jan.I do not really care for Penny, Erin,Jake and Ken as they are too typical and I'm really tired of seeing the bikini girls, the hero and the heart of gold old guys.They really need new writers for this show. I activly dislike Tedd, Brian, and Clay(male chavinists). I dislike ShiiAnn as I detest bossy women. Not sure about Stehanie, have to think about her.

Lycanthrope

Monday, October 14, 2002 - 06:18 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Okay, after episode 4, here's MHO:

Jake- Still strong, viewed as leader: 8

Ken- Likable fellow, will make merge: 8

Penny- Seems sweet, under radar: 8

Erin- Eye candy, allianced up well: 8

Robb- Seems kind of funny now, needs to align with someone other than Stephanie: 7

Shii Ann- Cocky, but candid in her confessionals, playing well so far: 8

Stephanie- Not fun to watch on T.V. at all, not playing a particularly good game: 3

Ted- In a strong alliance, but also strong individually: 9

Brian- Ditto Ted, but he's under the big radar right now: 10

Clay: The fact that he was targeted instead of Ted says he is not liked much, other than by Ted: 7

Jan- Weak player, a liability in challenges and is on the wrong side of the fence in her tribe: 4

Helen- Strong physically and mentally; playing a good game thus far: 9

Booted players: Liked Tanya, but not the other 3.

Sentimental favorite: Helen or Erin
Stategic favorite: Brian
Needs to go: Jan and Stephanie

Monkeyboy

Tuesday, October 15, 2002 - 09:15 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1.Shii Ann (AZ gal and very candid)
2.Helen (just like her)
3.Jan (sweet lookin for some reason...maybe since shes a teacher?)
4.Erin (ZZZZZZZ but is the lesser of many evils IMO)
5.Penny (see above comment)
6.Ken (not much to like IMO, boring but not as bad as the rest)
7.Jake (i just dont like him! so there! =D)
8.Stephanie (her b*tchy attitude sucks!)
9.Robb (still sh*tty,but as much as the three below)
10.Brian (His comments about women turned me off)
11.Clay (ARGH! GO HOME!)
12.Ted (GAGGGGGGG! thats all i can say...oh yea and GET OVER IT< ITS JUST A GAME!!!!!