How much did ShiiAnn tell the Chooeys?
TV ClubHouse: Archives: How much did ShiiAnn tell the Chooeys?
Catfat | Sunday, November 03, 2002 - 01:23 pm     Did she spill enough to make a difference? They showed here rambling on to (was it Clay?) while they were gathering wood, does anyone else remember anything? Maybe she was just complaining in general without being specific. |
Mak1 | Sunday, November 03, 2002 - 04:48 pm     Cat, she seemed to be giving specifics, but we didn't get to hear a lot of it, so we don't really know. I heard her say to Clay that Penny isn't as sweet as she appears, that she is manipulative. She was sure talking fast and furious, the first time I had seen her so animated, lol. If/when the tribes merge and go to their first TC, it may become more apparent if she did any actual damage. |
Queenfish | Sunday, November 03, 2002 - 06:34 pm     If memory serves, She was talking to Brian while gathering wood, and had previously opened up to Clay while checking out Chewy's beach before they moved over there. She said in the diary entry that she just started talking and couldn't stop. I think maybe she did give a bunch of info out to the chewys about the Sook tribe. I am looking forward to finding out Chewy's reaction when the Sooks return from tc without Shi Ann. That will speak volumes to the Chewy's, as I believe they had truly begun to like her. I have not enjoyed this season as much as the others, but maybe it will pick up some now. |
Car54 | Sunday, November 03, 2002 - 06:52 pm     Other than general stuff, she told them that Ken and Penny don't get along, about her prior votes, about how manipulative she thought Penny was. This could prove useful when they merge if they choose to annex any Sook players. |
Ginger1218 | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 05:44 am     Shi also was talking with Ted and told him that she was an outcast, and they both alluded to the possibility of it being a race or cultural thing. |
Jagger | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 07:12 am     I think she pretty much talked to all of them, and in the end it got her the boot. It might help the other team if they merge with even numbers, they might know who they could persuade to vote against one of their own members. |
Tabbyking | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 07:28 am     if the chuay gang believe most of what shii ann said about her tribe, and then see her gone, maybe they will just pick off the remaining sook members before starting on their own. the other thought is that they may decide her badmouthing her own tribe is what got her booted, and feel she deserved it. after all, they were only with her a short time compared to how long sook had been living with her.... i guess once we see their faces when they realize shii ann is gone, or hear their confessionals, we'll have an idea. |
Hermione69 | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 08:26 am     Shii Ann said in her interviews after the episode aired that she still thought CG was the best tribe and she is still friends with all of them. That points to them sympthazing with her, I think. Of course, as the last member of LL, she wouldn't have been privy to any more information about the remaining Survivors, so she wouldn't know what the CGs said. It will be interesting to find out, won't it? I especially want to see how the CGs interact with Penny since she is the one Shii Ann talked the most about. |
Catfat | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 08:44 am     I think that even though Shii got booted, she got her revenge, especially against Penny. Shii spent a lot of time telling people about Penny's overt antagonism. Ted will remember that and, combined with the probable racial overtones, hopefully work to get Penny booted when the tribes merge. |
Tabbyking | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 09:16 am     what is funny is how editing works...until last episode, i thought penny was a sweet little thing. before this episode, i only remember one time when she got in shii ann's (or anyone else's)face at all, and that was to tell her to stay out of the argument the guys were having over the bananas. remember oh.my.heck neleh? all of a sudden, she was agressive and out there, instead of flying under the radar. that is sort of how i see penny's face-time developing, too. whether both gals just got into the game at a certain point, or editing didn't bring out these characteristics until later, but they had been there all along, i don't know. we saw a lot of different things about the individuals last week! not sure how to take brian's 'kingdom' comments, for example, but don't think he is trying to be another 'rob-father'. i hope not! i will miss shii ann and will always wonder what would have happened had she made the (actual) merge. (???) |
Car54 | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 09:56 am     Ok, but some of the spoilers are saying that Penny outlasts all the other Sook-Jai's so maybe the CG's did not listen, or she is a better manipulator than we think. |
Tabbyking | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 12:23 pm     up til last episode, i had penny to definitely make final three. now i am thinking she may last another couple of weeks, but be out way before final 3. i still haven't seen much of what shii ann aluded to about penny, but again editing, editing, editing! i am disliking ken, whereas i used to like him. funny, too, how i didn't much care for helen at first, and now she is growing on me! it will also be interesting to see how jake and jan hold out, being as they are the oldest of the group. we haven't seen much of jake, really. didn't someone mention that penny had many of the CG tribe members at her wedding? she may just get in there and have them take right to her. will the texas bond keep some people together? questions, questions... gosh, i love surviiivor!! |
Micknrc | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 12:33 pm     Also, in the extra footage at CBS.com, it shows the convo between Brian and Penny when they were paired up in the paint-friends thing and they had a nice long chat about the small world factor--they are both UMD alums. (they're also only about 6 years apart in age. My first reaction, "Oh great, he'll pull her into the kingdom to off the others..." |
Hermione69 | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 12:53 pm     Tabby, according to the Enquirer, Clay is the CG that went to Penny's wedding. |
Tabbyking | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 02:16 pm     thanks, hermione69. makes me wonder if they bonded in camp or in 'loser lodge for the jurors'... this group is harder to 'know' than earlier ones. it doesn't seem as if we hear much about anyone's kids, i didn't know penny was engaged, we don't hear of hometown events, etc. perhaps editing again, because they must share some info, as usually some of the challenges involve knowing personal things about each other. |
Fruitbat | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 04:16 pm     One of the spoilers that puts Penny in the final three was a comment by someone close to the action but not under contract. (SS) He mentioned the blonde. Erins hair is streaked and getting lighter every day she is in the sun. In comparison to the dark haired players she could easily be considered a blonde. |
Catfat | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 04:48 pm     Jan's hair is blonde, too. Or was it only a Sucky player in the conversation? |
Hermione69 | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 05:00 pm     Or maybe someone young? I thought about Jan being blonde also, but she would never be mistaken for young, bless her heart. |
Fruitbat | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 05:31 pm     The spoiler mentions the older women (could be Helen) and a blonde and someone else. It is on SS. I do not give it much weight, just saying that Erin could be seen as blonde if not standing next to Penny. |
Niceguy | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 06:02 pm     Tabbyking, its those fleeting remarks the morning after tribal council that give the clues as to how these people are. I think that they're at their most raw and unguarded. Penny has said some really snide things about Jed, Steph and Robb. Ken is no angel but Penny is flat out dangerous. |
Catfat | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 06:03 pm     Jan's hair is blonde, too. Or was it only a Sucky player in the conversation? |
Tabbyking | Monday, November 04, 2002 - 07:32 pm     i could understand the snide things about robb! |
Risa | Wednesday, November 06, 2002 - 12:43 am     Hermi, I like what you said about Jan. She is a sweetheart. As to Shi, i never liked her until the last show. Now if she could have been that sweet from the start I'd of been in her corner. I hope whatever she told the Chuays works. I want to see Ken and Penny gone. I believe what Shi said about Penny being manipulative and Ken pulling that cop attitude. |
|