Archive through April 06, 2002
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

The ClubHouse: Archives: Survivors In The Order That You Like Them: Archive through April 06, 2002

Muse

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 07:08 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I remember we had this thread for S3. I'm curious to see how everyone feels about the individual Survivors at this point in the game.

I'm going to include those already voted off.

So starting with my favorite, I'd rank them like this:

Gina - Willing to play the game, but isn't nasty about it.
Hunter - Didn't deserve to go when he did.
Paschal - A total sweetie. :)
Neleh - Also adorable. I just wonder if she and Paschal have the cunning to stay in this game...
Kathy - Surprisingly, she's really grown on me. She can grate on my nerves at times, but I like her honesty and loyalty. Plus she always gives 100% at the challenges.
Robert - I think he's basically a nice guy. Hoping he switches alliances at some point.
Patricia - Yep, definitely a nagging mother type.
Gabe - A little clueless, but very well-intentioned.
Tammy - Seems pretty intelligent. I do think she definitely has the ability to be cutthroat at times, though.
Zoe - Who?
Vecepia - Again, who? I think she's trying to stay under the radar more than anyone else in the game...I don't really like that since it's very boring to watch. :) I also question the fact that she chose to align with Rob, Sean, and Sarah early on.
Peter - Fruit loop.
Sarah - She just rode on Rob's coattails, I think. Not the sharpest knife in the drawer. And I think she only came on Survivor to land a Playboy deal.
Rob, Sean, John - All despicable. I can't decide who's worse anymore. I think it *might* be Rob and/or Sean, but John's arrogance has just gotten out of hand.

Awareinva

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 07:49 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Zoe- quiet and out to win
Vee- so UTR, was she even there this week?
Paschal-a real sweetie
Neleh- a little too cutie pie for me but nice
Kathy- unbelievably I like her a lot more than at the beginning
Robert- not sure about him, I might like him
Tammy- just something about her I don't like, she may be ok with more air time
John- I don't like the "I am in charge" attitude, but he is there to win the game
Sean- don't like some of his comments, but he isn't THAT bad
Rob- I love him for the fun he adds, but can't like him at all for the ugly things he said

Urgrace

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 09:54 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Tammy She is playing this game to win, plays fair, and works hard. She walks away from conflict and joins in on the comradery. She does not have a poker face and shows her emotions.
Robert He has not done or said anything to make me not like him so far. UTR
Zoe Cool lady. Yeah, she lied to Rob 'cause she doesn't like him and won't stoop to his power trip. I just hope they don't see her as too powerful herself and give her the axe.
Neleh What a sweetie. A really nice young woman who may be too young to strategize on her own, but has an encouraging outlook on the game.
Vee Cool headed, smart, finally easing out of the reach of the dumb and dumber duo while flying UTR.
Kathy What a hard worker. She just doesn't know how to stratagize and is not a leader, although she tries with 150%. Glad she's still there.
Paschal The judge is a nice guy, but he is getting weaker and weaker physically. It will take his brains to get him all the way to final 4.
Sean He has been playing his own game so far and doesn't have what it takes to win. Too bad his attitude stinks.
John He has joined the dumb and dumber duo to make it the dumbest trio. Way too self-absorbed which clouds his thinking and actions.
Rob This Will Kirby wannabe pushes my buttons.

I don't miss any of the players who have been voted out.

Mygetaway

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 10:04 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I really liked Gina, dang it! I guess it would go something like this...
I don't have strong feelings for anyone to win yet, but I strongly dislike Rob, John and Sean.
I like Neleh, and kind of like Kathy now.
Paschal is ok, but I don't have big feelings for him like I did Rodger.
Zoe seems interesting, but don't know her well yet, same as Tammy. I liked Vee before, she may still be ok.
I'm neutral on Robert.
If you twisted my arm and made me choose right now, I think I'd have to say Neleh as my fav at this moment in time.

Moondance

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 10:05 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
>I really liked Gina, dang it! I guess it would go something like this...
I don't have strong feelings for anyone to win yet, but I strongly dislike Rob, John and Sean. <

I completely agree:)

Maris

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 10:16 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I saw all the posts about Gina but I never thought she would be ejected. I had a secret wish that Paschal would sacrifice himself like a good old roger. Unfortunately, it wasnt to be. I dont know if I like anyone either except maybe Kathy, although she didnt impress me this week. I absolutely cant stand Rob, john and Sean. I would like to see John go next, then Rob and then Sean.

Urgrace

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 11:04 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Maris, I was hoping the same thing about Paschal offering to be voted off.

I put the people in order of who I like, and not necessarily who I think will win. Nobody (but maybe Acme) knows what will happen next and who wins. Everything changes each week, and all of us are playing the game totally different from the actual survivors! (Don't know why we get so flustered when it always happens like that. Look at Will winning BB. He should have been voted off in the first few weeks, but NOOOO he won!)

Mygetaway

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 11:16 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Maris and Urgrace.. I posted this over in the Spoiler thread Was anyone else hoping that Pappy's heart was so broken, that he would sacrifice himself for the good of the family? He was having a hard time on the relay race, and I was hoping he would tell them to vote him off. Oh well.
I think Paschal will end up going far, only because he isn't a threat. They will want to vote the bad guys off first. He seems really nice, but I just don't get the warm fuzzies from him..

Urgrace

Thursday, April 04, 2002 - 11:31 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
When they merge they should be looking to vote off the strongest threats for individual immunity. Paschal makes it to the merge which gives him a lot better chance of sticking around for a while, unless he becomes ill. A lot of the strongest members have already been voted off which is not ordinarily the way this game is played. It makes for a very interesting future of this Survivor, since it is not playing out as usual.

Webkitty

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:07 am EditMoveDeleteIP
All my favorites are gone now....Kathy would have to head up my s$it list at this point. Never did like her and like her less now. The bandana doesn't help, not one bit.

With that said, still going with my "theory" on who the top two will be...Kathy/Rob. (I was SURE it was Gina )
Looking back to the beginning, camera time, story thread, its got to be those two.

Squaredsc

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:10 am EditMoveDeleteIP
ok here are my fav's for the way they play the game and they seem ok to me, and i know my choices aren't even close to the rest of you but that's what makes this fun.
Rob
John
Sean
Tammy
Vee
Robert(love his tatoos)
Kathy
Zoe, Neleh, Pappy


sorry don't have enough time to put the why 'cause i am at work but may put the why on later.

Bidasea

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 08:36 am EditMoveDeleteIP
ZOEbut she should have said"Yeah Rob, I'm in an alliance.Don't worry about my plans for the game, worry about yourself"
TAMMY
ROBERT
VEE,smart, and a clever player

KATHY,grating personality, but a player

NELEH/PAPPY, boring, boring, but nice..I will be interested to see how she plays off Rob
JOHN--Too mean spirited for me..Nasty little guy.
SEAN--He's just playing the game.He'd turn on Vee and stab her in the back in an instant.
rob....I wouldn't want to meet up with him in a dark alley..I think he is trying to be like Will from BB, but he's really more like Justin...I wish Zoe had of looked him right in the eye and told him to stuff it...

Tksoard

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 08:44 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I was thinking the same thing, Bidasea. I wanted her to just tell hem to mind his own game. Maybe it was edited to make it look like she was really listening to his crap. I hope so!! I want to see those two get into it BAD!! She could really give him a run for his money, but hopefully it'll be hers!!

Julieboo

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 12:09 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Hi
I can't even put John in the same category as Sean & Rob. But I thought this was a good piece of advice for John:

One reason Richard Hatch was so successful was that everybody didn’t know he was in charge. He was the puppeteer who allowed his marionettes to think they had free will. That’s why he won. And that’s why I’m betting you won’t.

Grooch

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 12:22 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Rob is my favorite, right now. He is so evil.

Llkoolaid

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 12:50 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I am doing this the way Square did. I don't know any of them so I can't say I like them but the ones that I want to see stay in the mix for entertainment value are:

Rob
John
Sean
Kathy
Paschal
Tammy
Zoe
Robert
Neleh
Vee

Julieboo

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 12:56 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Let's see (of the ones left)
in order of entertainment:
ya know, I'll take llkoolaid's list in the same order.

in order of who I actually like (NOT necessarily who I think should win):
Neleh
Paschal
Zoe
John
Robert
Kathy
Tammy
Ve
Sean
Rob

Hippyt

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:04 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
You know,I came to post,and realized I really have no favorites this show!! I always had a favorite in the other Survivors,some one to cheer on,but I don't care who wins this one right now!I'm sure I will,I love the show.
Rob would be my favorite right now,just for entertainment value!!

Llkoolaid

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:15 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I feel the same way Hippyt, I am loving this show more than the others but I just can't find someone to cheer for.
Don't anyone throw rotten tomatoes but I am leaning towards Rob because of the way everyone doesn't like him. In survivor 1 I was a Richard fan right from the start and everyone hated him. In survivor 2 it was Keith, and 3 it was Frank (I liked to look at Ethan). It amazes me how the most disliked is able to get so far in these games. I am kinda pulling for Kathy too.
It's not that I like them but I just find it amusing at how much they get away with. I would far sooner see them win than someone who fly UTW like Tena and Mamakim.

Webkitty

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:25 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Kool, Tina didn't really win S2, Colby LET her.

Llkoolaid

Friday, April 05, 2002 - 06:36 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I know Grrrrr, I was so mad I remember thinking you are so stupid Colby you don't deserve to win. He had it if he had of kept Keith. I don't really think he picked Tena because he was such a good sport. He was just stupid. I think he picked Tena because he felt that the jury would have given the game to Keith for spite for dumping Tena. I think he really thought that keeping Tena would make him look like a good sport and fair player in the eyes of the jury, especially after he won so many rewards. Noble my butt, he was trying to win it all and it blew up in his face. ( Can you tell I wasn't a Colby fan)

C1mag

Saturday, April 06, 2002 - 02:23 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Fav's from one to ten:

Robfather: He's a pig, but he's great tv. At this point I wouldn't mind if he won or at least made the journey bumpy for the others.

Kathy: She's got headcase written all over her, but this woman is a competitor. She is also great tv.

Sean: Facial expressions crack me up. Won me over with the Tony Robins comment. It wouldn't be any good without him and Rob there together.

Tammy: I like her. I think this one's got independant spunk that we have yet to see.

Robert: The man knows how to play!!! Like him and admire his ability to tolerate John. Use him and then boot him in the end!

Zoe: Not a good liar, but has potential. Love the cat like grin she has.

Vee: Smart cookie. Creates no enemies! This type slips by.

Neleh: Has potential, but needs to ditch the old koot FAST!! Why do these young girls latch on to the grandpas of the group?

John: I like the drama he offers but too much of a Richard Hatch wanna be. Big difference is that he just doesn't get it. Subtle will get you far. Blatant will get you booted. I want him around for a while but he's like nails on a chalk board to me.

Paschal: This old man makes me want to hurl! I can't stand him. How pathetic to come into a game where there is only one winner and you are crying because someone else got booted. What was he gonna do? Give Gabe the money? He makes my skin crawl with the family like atmosphere he desires to have. Thats not what this game is about. Way too lovey dovey for me. Neleh could be a real force if he would go back to the old folks home. He is my least liked player of the remaining ten. If he wins I will pass out... hahahaha!

Actually I have no favorite that I'm routing for to take the top prize. I am just enjoying the drama and fight for power. It keeps me watching. However, I will love it when the old man is sent home! Other than that any of them could take it and I'd be ok with it. Even John. If his game plan is accepted and he makes it through then that's the way it goes.

Llkoolaid

Saturday, April 06, 2002 - 04:23 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Actually I have no favorite that I'm routing for to take the top prize. I am just enjoying
the drama and fight for power

That's how I feel about this survivor C1mag.

Egbok

Saturday, April 06, 2002 - 10:04 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Top half likables, not in any particular order:
Tammy
Neleh
Zoe
Vee
Robert
Paschal
Kathy(okay, she's in a particular order! LOL)

These guys bring "flavor" to the show, but I don't care for them:
John
Rob
Sean

Pamy

Saturday, April 06, 2002 - 11:38 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Julie.. I agree with you about why John is not like rich Hatch, and that is why I think Rob will go far. He has shown he can be a puppet master and the others have no clue. Every week we were sure WIll was going on BB2 but he ends up winning, that might happen here with Rob