Archive through May 03, 2002
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

The ClubHouse: Archives: Survivors In The Order That You Like Them: Archive through May 03, 2002

Urgrace

Friday, April 19, 2002 - 05:01 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Some of you need the 'fickle finger award'! LOL

Nanya

Friday, April 19, 2002 - 05:25 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I want them outta here draft 3
JOHN IS GONE!!!!
1. Tammy
2. Zoe
3. Robert
4. Pascal(I didn't like his "someone like Sean" remark)
5. Neleh
6. Sean
7. Vee
8. AND THE WINNER IS KATHY

Muse

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 08:03 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1) Kathy - The recap and the lastest episode just confirmed my opinion of her.

2) Neleh - Smart, cute, trying not to hurt anyone. I do think that she, Sean, Vee, Paschal, and Kathy do need to realize that they have formed a new alliance, though. And if they don't tone it down, they're really not all that different from the old alliance.

3) Paschal - It was really nice to see Paschal and Sean bonding like that...I think Paschal still sees Sean's flaws (like laziness), but has come to respect Sean for his good qualities as well.

4) Vecepia - She's okay...not all that interesting, but it was sweet how she (and others) were so excited for Sean and Paschal when they won the RC.

5) Sean - I haven't forgotten what he used to be like...he's been *much* more likable since Rob left, though.

6) Robert and Tammy (tie) - I think Robert is ultimately more likable for some reason, but his pouting and hypocrisy got on my nerves tonight.

And if she was still around - I'd probably put Zoe after Vecepia. I do think she honestly liked Kathy, Neleh, and Paschal better than her fellow alliance members, and was never 100% committed to her alliance because of that. But still - she wanted to go where the power fell, even if that meant breaking her word or betraying friendships.

Nanya

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 08:30 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I want them outta here!! Draft 4
John is GONE!
Zoe is GONE!
1. Robert
2. Tammy
3. Pascal(I'm still peeved)
4. Neleh
5. Sean
6. Kathy
7....AND THE WINNER IS VECEPIA!
I am so fickle

Wink

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 09:09 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Next year someone please remind me how skillful MB is at rehabilitating players he portrays in such a poor light in the early shows. There was no trace at all tonite of that angry young man who got me so riled up in the early going.

I realize editing and context have much to do with the Sean who was presented early on and I'm still pissed at some of the statements he made but tonite he was so charming and so endearing that he and Kathy are my new faves for final 2. I think both of them have managed to truly survive to become two of the most memorable characters ever on Survivor.

Knightpatti

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 09:39 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
If this was the first show you ever show this series, you would probably rate Sean has number one. He was just so human tonight. Missing his Mom, appreciating life and every moment that he was having. Smuggling the food for the others was great, too.

My list:
1. Kathy - she is the underdog from the beginning. I hope that she makes it all the way.
2. Neleh - she is a cutie and sweet girl.
3. Sean another underdog that would surprise us all if he makes it to the final 2.
4. Pappy = only because of tonight's show. I did not like MamaKim and I would hate to think he is playing this game by who goes by his judgments of people.
5. Vee = I do not find her very interesting at all and have not really gotten to know her.
6. Robert = he is ok, but I do not know him either.
7. Tammy - can not stand her. I think she is a very sour person.

Mygetaway

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 11:15 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
I'd have to say that at this point:
Kathy is my favorite for winner.
Then Neleh, I guess.
Sean moved up the list some tonight. I was a single Mom for 10 years, and his comments hit home for me. Plus I really LOVED the whole Pappy and him reward thing.
Vee, I liked her in the beginning, but she's just kinda so-so.
Paschal/Robert.. Pappy was kind of nice tonight. I loved him and Sean bonding, but otherwise, I have no real feelings for him. Robert seems ok, but he's been too much in the background, and I didn't like his pouting tonight.
Tammy is last I guess, because she's been a biatch herself, BUT, I think she's an awesome competitor, and if she got further in the game, I wouldn't be totally disappointed.

Weinermr

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 11:27 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Kathy
Neleh
Paschal
Sean
Robert/Vee Vee/Robert
Tammy

Seamonkey

Thursday, April 25, 2002 - 11:33 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Neleh
Sean
Paschal
Kathy
Vee
Robert
Tammy

Realtvfan

Friday, April 26, 2002 - 07:25 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1) Kathy - she knows how to play this game. A few mistakes here and there but she is working very hard and playing very smart.

2) Vee - she is able to ride the emotional waves of both camps very well. I'll give her quite a bit of credit for that.

3) Neleh - She saw what happened with the coconuts and she took the inititive to do something about it. I'll give her credit for that.

4) Tammy - She was fighting for immunities and she wants to play. I appreciate those efforts.

5) General - Thursday night's whining was not a good sign for the General. I appreciate his realization for his situation, but he did not handle it well.

6) Pascal - Super huge mistake with John (when he did not have to do it) or I would make him my number one favorite ahead of Kathy.

7) Sean - I still remember Sean's behavior when he was on the outside with out the support of the numbers. I look to measure people by their behavior when they are down. Not how nice they can be when they are up. Everyone can be nice when they are up.

Webkitty

Friday, April 26, 2002 - 07:59 am EditMoveDeleteIP
It changes all the time for me.

I have to say Robert is on the bottom of the list now that Zoe is gone. Never did like him and like him less now. I agree with Real that a measure of a person is how they act when their down. His behavior was to pout and act surly. At least Tammy went off by herself to practice the stilts instead of just mopeing.

I'm not that impressed with Vee either. These under the radar people that coast to the finish w/o every having won an immunity or really contributing that much bother me. She is SUPPOSED to be in a tight alliance with Sean, but interupted that trust by voting agaist Rob, I just don't respect her for that.

I have to give Tammy credit for having grit and determination. She was smug when she was in the controlling alliance, but that is human nature. I can see some smugness creeping into Nelah and Pappy, especially Nelah.

Pappy, I just don't know about him. He broke his "sacred" word to John, he never wins anything, what does he really contribute? I still don't think he trusts or likes Sean as much as some other people do, and I think he would vote Sean off in a heartbeat.

Nelah I was liking alot, but like I said, I can see her getting smug, I'll give her another show to see how I feel then. She doesn't win any immunities, I don't see how she "worked that hard" but........

Sean, I'm liking him more but I also remember what he was like in the beginning. I will give him the benifit of the doubt and say it was the famous MB editing, for now.
Crying for his mother was a plus for me. I felt it was genuine, spontanious and from the heart.

Kathy, oh Kathy! From the very first show this gal (along with Zoe) irritated me no end!
BUT, she is growing on me. I think she is the most skilled player there. At this point, I am going to say she deserves to win the most of anyone. Just PLEASE loose that headband!!! (I'll be good and won't say anything about the bra, ooops! I just did!)

Guinevere

Friday, April 26, 2002 - 11:53 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I'd be okay with Paschal, Neleh, Kathy, and maybe even Sean winning. I'm not crazy in love with any of them, but my order of liking probably goes like this:

1) Neleh - she can be a little annoying, but she went up so much in my estimation last week when she had the sense and spine to save herself.

2) Paschal - pretty much the same as Neleh, except I get the feeling she's just slightly more on the ball than him.

3) Sean - this is a hard one - I'm not being fickle because I think he has been a real jerk at certain times, and no, it's not just the editing. Editing can't make a man compare doing his fair share to slavery. But, the thing is, Sean is by far the most charming of the people left. Rob was the same way before he left; he could be a real creep, but when he was showing so much personality, it was easy to forget.

4) Kathy - damn, she can really be annoying, but it's hard not to root for her - she's been such an underdog throughout.

5) Robert - despite his sourness last night, I think he's okay. He's been pretty cool throughout the show (though some of that may just be his utr skills - witness how unlikeable Zoe became, the more you saw of her), and I think he can be forgiven some disappointment at the way things collapsed for his alliance.

6) Tammy - I don't like her (or her little smirk), but I have to admire that she is a real competitor and is playing the game.

7) Vee - just don't like her. She's like Old Kim, trying to skate by, not even giving the viewing public their money's worth by being entertaining. She hasn't shown a lot of loyalty. I can understand her trying to save herself (when she and Rob and Sean came over to Rotu) by disassociating herself from the "drama" somewhat. But it just seems sort of chickensh*t to me in a way; I mean, it wasn't like she had some big plan to climb up the ladder. She's a boring follower, ala Amber.

Gina8642

Saturday, April 27, 2002 - 08:14 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Gosh, so much not liking here.

I just have to say that I like all the remaining players. Of all the players left before Zoe was voted out, only Zoe was rubbing me the wrong way. And even then, not much. Her protrayal in the last episode and her interview on the Morning Show did not improve my impression.

But really, I like them all.

I've been rooting for Kathy for quite a long time, just 'cause I'm a sucker for the underdog.

Now that Tammy looks like a marked woman, I've sorta started hoping she can pull something off.

Robert is in the dumps - no biggie. His attitude seems no different than Sean's, when Sean figured he had zero chance right after the merge. Everyone has down days, not everyone has cameras following them around, magnifying the mood.

Like Webkitty was saying, smugness can be seen in whomever is in the most control at a given moment. Nor does it look pretty on whomever is displaying it at the moment.

No matter who wins at this point I'll be happy.

(Unless of course, someone flips out and shows a very negative side.)

Busterfla

Tuesday, April 30, 2002 - 07:34 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Neleh
2. Kathy
3. Pappy
4. Vee
5. Sean

The General & Tammy ??? How low can I go ?

Nessietessie

Wednesday, May 01, 2002 - 05:39 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Kathy, because I think she could really survive in a survival situation if she had to.

2. Neleh, because I like her personality,

3. Pascal, because he is down to earth, surprising considering his profession.

4. Tammy, I do not care for her personality, but she could survive in a survival situation.

5. Vee, I have no clue about her.

6. Sean, is #6 because I remember how he did not contribute to helping out,
and first few shows showed what an angry man he is.

7. Robert, has not contributed anything, and showed a sullen, pouty, side last week.

Muse

Thursday, May 02, 2002 - 07:37 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1) Kathy - She's awesome. I like her more with every passing episode.

2) Paschal - Really nice guy. I didn't like the fact that he invited Neleh (rather than Vee) to join him on the cruise ship, though. I wish strategy would factor into his decisions and actions more.

3) Neleh - She was silly this episode, but overall I still find her likable. Like Kathy said - she's *mostly* honestly sweet.

4) Robert - What can I say...I thought it was sweet how he was so upset to see Tammy go. And I was happy to see him stop pouting.

5) Sean - Really didn't like the wishy-washy attitude. He prides himself in not breaking promises...so stick to that. And it's sort of weird that *he* is criticizing others (Sarah, now Neleh) for being lazy, when so many others say the same thing about him.

6) Vecepia - She would probably be above Sean in my list, but Sean is just so amusing. :) Vee is just kind of...there. And she seems to be even more wishy-washy than Sean. I do think she's a nice enough person, though.

Hippyt

Thursday, May 02, 2002 - 08:21 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Hmmm,
1)Sean- I know,I'm sooo controversial and all,but he's really the only funny one left,I loved the doo-doo comment tonight!
2)Kathy- I'd love to see her win! She is doing a great job playing this game!
3)Paschal- He's not a good strategist,but how can you not like him? He's having the time of his life.
4)Robert-he's gone next,but he won tonight,and he worked hard,shows he is playing the game
5)Neleh- She would probably be at the bottom of my list if Vee weren't such a no-show! She got on my nerves tonight. She is playing this game,and she's playing everyone else!
6)Vee-gets last place by default. I haven't seen her show any skills at this game,or say much either. It would be funny if she went to the finals by blindly following Sean though!

Seamonkey

Thursday, May 02, 2002 - 09:15 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Like:
1.Neleh
2.Paschal
3.Kathy
4.Sean
5.Vee
6.Robert

Cliotheleo

Thursday, May 02, 2002 - 09:43 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
In order of most liked:

1. Sean
2. Pappy
3. Rob and Vee
5. Kathy and Neleh

I don't think Vee is so quick to blindly follow Sean as it may seem. Remember she voted to oust Rob M? She is perhaps closest to Sean, but ultimately Vee is playing the game for Vee. Tina Wesson became the ultimate survivor in part by flying under the radar. But the trick is to fly under the radar without anyone noticing that's what you're doing and ousting you because of it. So far I think Vee is doing a pretty good job of that.

Sunshinemiss

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 01:30 am EditMoveDeleteIP
In order of best to worst...

1) Hunter
2) Boston Rob
3) Gabe
4) Gina

Huh? What? They're all gone? Oh my heck. Well then

1) Kathy.. hard worker, smart.
2) Sean .. I think this experience is changing him. He seems more open and considerate (SEEMS may be the operative word though)
3) Paschal.. good hearted, straight forward.
4) Vee
5) Neleh .. needs to grow up a bit
6) The Grumpy General. Too negative for me. Buh-bye, next tribal council.

Now, this is who I like, not necessarily in the order I think will win. And is, of course, subject to (in fact, practically guaranteed to) change at a moments notice.

Llkoolaid

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 05:04 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1: Sean and Kathy, I can't decide.
2: Robert
3: Vee
4: Paschal, sometimes I get an icky feeling when I look at him. good a reason as any
5: Neleh, I hate sugar and she is just plain syrup. She lost me tonight with the candy. Why didn't they dump a couple of bowls of those candy in their bags. I think she is gone next week.

Fruitbat

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 10:05 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Kathy just moved up on my list and lives with Sean at the top. Neleh plummeted to the bottom where she will remain with Paschall by her side. To heck with them.

Lancecrossfire

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 10:12 am EditMoveDeleteIP
<I hand Bat a rotating door> hehe

Weinermr

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 10:17 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Kathy
Neleh
Paschal
Vee
Sean
Robert

Micknrc

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 10:57 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Robert
Sean
Kathy
Paschal
Vee
Neleh