Archive through May 17, 2002
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

The ClubHouse: Archives: Survivors In The Order That You Like Them: Archive through May 17, 2002

Fruitbat

Friday, May 03, 2002 - 11:25 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I like Robert too Micknrc. Lance thanks, I may need that door in the future.

Nanya

Saturday, May 04, 2002 - 10:55 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I want them outta here DRAFT 5
1.Robert
2.Neleh
3.Paschal
4.Sean
5.Vecepia
6.AND THE WINNER IS KATHY!!

Angelnikki

Sunday, May 05, 2002 - 03:00 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. sean
2. kathy
3. paschal
4. robert
5. neleh
6. vee

Seamonkey

Thursday, May 09, 2002 - 09:11 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Time for the weekly reshuffle..

1. Neleh
2. Paschal
3. Kathy
4. Vee
5. Sean

The visitors..

Favorite visitor, Leander.. Vee is right; he's just adorable.

Fruitbat

Thursday, May 09, 2002 - 09:41 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
After tonight? I love them all. I was crying like a baby.

Sunriverose

Thursday, May 09, 2002 - 09:50 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Hi, Here are my favs:(but not the order i really believe they will finish in) (excuse my dangling participle)

Kathy
Sean
Paschal
Vee
Nelah

I don't know why I'm picking on poor little nelah, no good reason at all really, I just think she will go next.
My favs based on what I think of as finish positions

Nelah goes next
then pappy
Then Kathy gets immun
Vee goes
Sean and Kathy F2
Jury votes for Kathy. But they might just vote for Sean because he has shown so much character recently.

Llkoolaid

Thursday, May 09, 2002 - 10:10 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
What Sunrivrose said is what I think will happen too. and I like them in the same order. Next week is going to be so good. I am going to be on the edge of my seat hoping that Neleh goes. I am sick of little miss sunshine. Sorry to all her fans but I just don't believe in her. I can't decide between who I want to win, Kathy or Sean and maybe even Pappy but I don't want Vee or Neleh to win. I like the ones that put themselves out there and have to fight their way to the finish rather the ones that fly under the radar and hang on other peoples coat tails.

Mygetaway

Thursday, May 09, 2002 - 11:14 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Kathy
Vee/Sean/Neleh
Paschal
Nothing against Paschal really, I just don't get the warm fuzzies for him.
I'm thinking Kathy and Sean for F2 also.

Nessietessie

Friday, May 10, 2002 - 06:07 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Paschal (altho he showed poor judgement
when taking Nelah on the cruise. I do not
think he should have taken Vee either,
even tho it was her birthday, she DID quit.
I think he should have taken the person
who came in second, I think it was Tammy.
Then there would have been no hard feelings.)
2. Kathy, hard worker, good survival skills
3. Sean, funny, but I still think he is lazy
4. Nelah, immature, but kind of cute
5. Vee, has not shown any survival skills,
except playing under the radar, not too
much personality

Muse

Friday, May 10, 2002 - 06:46 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1) Paschal - Nice, tries to be fair.
2) Kathy - A very close second. She'll probably go up to #1 or waaaay down based on her decision next week. I *really* don't want to see her pick S/V over P/N.
3) Neleh - I don't want to see her win, but she's nice enough.
4) Sean - Mean-spirited.
5) Vecepia - A bit mean-spirited herself, but tries to act like she's not...I also doubt that she has any loyalty towards anyone except herself.

Tess

Friday, May 10, 2002 - 08:06 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Paschal
Neleh
Kathy
Vee
Sean

Cliotheleo

Friday, May 10, 2002 - 09:31 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Sean
2. Vee and Pappy
3. Kathy
4. Neleh (I know it's the editing but the screaming is getting to me.)

Pamy

Friday, May 10, 2002 - 10:16 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Sean, he has totally grown on me, makes me mad the way he was edited at first, making us all dislike him so much
2. Kathy, same as above
3. Paschal, doesn't irrate me as much as the next picks
4. Vee, she still seems a little fake to me
5. Neleh, I know it is probably the editing but she really is getting on my last nerve!

Webkitty

Saturday, May 11, 2002 - 04:58 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
The thing about Neleh and Pappy is that they have not had to step out of their comfort zone once.

They latched onto each other right from the start, and even when the tribes switched, they got to stick together. They went to a better beach, with a better variety of food that was easier to get, and were welcomed by Gina, who was nice to them.
They didn't have to deal with any turmoil, they had just come from the "love" tribe and missed all the stress going on in the "new" Rotu.

Then, when the tribes merged, they stuck their necks out oh so carefully, together, and came up golden for their efforts.

They both got to go on the best reward so far, together.

Nothing has been hard for them. I can see why Sean made the Disney comment. Its like they have skipped and jumped their way to the end, holding hands, humming all the way to the pot of gold.

Outlast, it looks like it. But they are missing the other two elements of the game. IMO

I don't have anything against them, I'm sure they are both nice people, but in the context of this game, I don't think either one deserves to win compared to the efforts of some of the others.
Neither one has really had to TRY that hard.

For being all alone and not being in any alliance, either for saftey or comfort, I am going to say Kathy has outplayed everyone.

Sean and Vee have had some comfort from each other. Although Sean has not always been PC, he has stuck his neck out and played the game, so I'm giving him second place.

Vee has choosen to fly under the radar, and once again, I'm sure she's a very nice person, I don't care for those under the radar type players.

1. Kathy
2. Sean
3. Vee
4. Pappy
5. Neleh

I guess this is not so much who I "like" but who I think deserves to "win" on how they played the game, from my viewpoint.

Gina8642

Sunday, May 12, 2002 - 11:50 am EditMoveDeleteIP
I still like them all. I'm still rooting for Kathy to win. I can't pick a favorite, even when I try.

Shakes

Monday, May 13, 2002 - 11:00 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Kathy - played the best game
2. Sean - great TV, decent game
3. Neleh - on my last nerve, but she stepped up to the plate with the John boot.
4. Paschal - nice old guy, too much with Neleh
5. Vee - I can't stand the UTR players or should I say non-players (boring, boring, boring).

Give me Kathy/Sean F2 with a Kathy win please.

Squaredsc

Monday, May 13, 2002 - 01:00 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
sean is still my top pick, the rest don't really matter to me, imo. but i would love to see the outtakes or whatever they call it when they sell the video of the scenes that we don't get to see, i never thought of getting the tapes for the other survivors, but i would definately want this seasons'.

Guinevere

Monday, May 13, 2002 - 01:59 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1) Kathy - irritating but plucky

2) Neleh - also irritating, but I think she's played well when she needed to

3) Paschal - pretty much interchangeable with Neleh, but I think she's a little bit more of the leader of the two (which is why it irritates me when Sean says she's riding Paschal's coattails. I know he sees stuff we don't, but from what I've seen that's not the case, and so the comments come off as sexist/ageist on Sean's part).

4) Sean - I could actually live with him winning. I do like him sometimes - he is cute and can be very funny. But he can also be a big fat jerk and I'm tired of softening on him only to have him act like a total ass (oh, yeah, the others are SOOOO making racist assumptions thinking that you and Vee are allied. Not.)

5) Vecepia - the only one I would be really disapointed to see win. I just don't like her. I think she's milked the under the radar thing; that might be a sound strategy but it doesn't make for good television or earn my respect (I couldn't stand OldKim last season either). Pretends to be sweetness and light, but shows no loyalty and makes snarky comments (referring to Neleh as "the Mormon girl") behind peoples' backs.

Angelnikki

Monday, May 13, 2002 - 04:48 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
1. sean
2. kathy
3. paschal
4. vecepia
5. neleh

Muse

Thursday, May 16, 2002 - 07:42 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Man, after that most recent episode, I'm finding that I only really like one of the people left! :(

But if I had to choose:

1) Kathy - I can totally understand why she'd get rid of Sean after his big outburst at TC. Now she can either form an alliance with Vecepia (in hopes of making the final two) or stick with Neleh and Paschal out of loyalty. I wouldn't blame her for going either way. Go Kathy!

2) Neleh - Not a big fan, but she's okay, I guess. She plays the game pretty well.

3) Paschal - Oh, Pappy...what happened to you? Lex-like paranoia and nastiness? I'm not a fan of Sean myself, but Paschal just went a little too far tonight. But I still think there's more good than bad in him, and I was impressed by how he easily turned Sean's argument (about an alliance with Vee) against him at TC. Guess being a lawyer and judge did pay off.

4) Vecepia - The most likable in this episode, but still largely a non-entity. Sorry, but one of those kind of personas got second place last season, and I'm not interested in seeing it happen again. Plus I think she has a nasty streak that she shows on rare occasions (Neleh as "the Mormon girl" reference, constantly shifting alliances, etc), just like the rest of them.

Sunriverose

Thursday, May 16, 2002 - 11:20 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
KATHY
everyone else.

Seamonkey

Thursday, May 16, 2002 - 11:53 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Neleh
Kathy
Paschal
Vee

I don't love any of them; don't hate any of them.

I think Vee has done less to "win".

Kathy has overcome many obstacles, most of her own making.. she dug a deep hole initially, but was saved by first being on an unbeatable team, and next being on the other team which came with a built in scapegoat (Sarah and then Gina) so that she was safely away when the unbeatable team was finally beaten.

By the time she returned she had the alliance with Rob and Rob's confrontation of John, Zoe and others. That helped Kathy.

Then Neleh and Paschal turning away from the "Rotu Five" happens to be a factor in keeping Kathy, Sean and Vee around this long, since they were slated to go in that order.

But Kathy's kept her head on straight and been able to benefit from all of these factors.

The decision to not ally with Rob.. hard to say if that was good or bad..

She got immunity this week and that was HER doing (though it was close and only due to Neleh dropping her icon further away than Kathy dropped hers, otherwise, Neleh would have been immune).

So while I do think Kathy's hung in there, there were many factors that saved her along the way.

Paschal.. I certainly didn't see him as "mean" tonight. Sometimes the truth hurts. This came up because Sean asked for immunity and couldn't stand the fire that ensued. Kathy would NOT let him gloss over.. well actually Jeff first wouldn't let him, by pointing out that Sean personally couldn't guanrantee Kathy anything and since Sean was maintaining that he had no alliance, his bluff was called. He tried to outshout and outbluster but Kathy wasn't having any of it.

Paschal was answering to the accusations that Neleh and Paschal had "hidden" their alliance.
Again, Kathy wasn't letting that be her issue.. it had gone over her head, maybe she wasn't paying attention way way back with the original Rotu, even we at home heard Neleh say she would have a hard time ever voting for Paschal. I don't think Paschal and Neleh ever hid their alliance and pretty obviously Kathy doesn't think they HID it either.

So.. Sean's volume and quantity didn't convince anyone.

Add to that his demonstrated strength in the Reward challenge and he was a marked man.

I'd be fine with anyone but Vee winning at this point.

And Kathy is right; Immunity is key now.

And now that I've also committed the sin of too much volume (and I don't blame Sean for trying, just wish he'd been straight with them earlier), I think it is time to sleep.

Tess

Friday, May 17, 2002 - 12:08 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Paschal
Neleh
Kathy
Vee

Micknrc

Friday, May 17, 2002 - 06:08 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Kathy

and...uh...erm...


NOBODY!

Car54

Friday, May 17, 2002 - 06:22 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Me too, Mick! I think we should get to take the money awarded to F2 and 3 positions and give it to charity this year. I am really cranky about last night.