Tonights show: 2/4
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

TV ClubHouse: Archive: American Idol (FOX): Tonights show: 2/4
 SubtopicMsgs  Last Updated
Archive through February 04, 2003 25   02/04 05:22pm
Archive through February 04, 2003 25   02/04 05:36pm
Archive through February 04, 2003 25   02/04 05:50pm
Archive through February 04, 2003 25   02/04 07:09pm
Archive through February 04, 2003 25   02/05 06:05am
Archive through February 05, 2003 25   02/05 11:05am
Archive through February 05, 2003 25   02/10 04:10pm

Webkitty

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 03:57 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Yes, after getting a tongue lashing from Julia's sister, putting up with Julia's pouting ways all evening, and sitting there and taking Julia's snotty remarks, Kim did stick her tongue out at Julia as she walked away.
What a b!tch that Kim is!!!! You guys nailed it, Kim is not deserving of moving on, how could I be so wrong............

Actually, watching it again, I am amazed that Kim didn't do more, she never uttered a word, wait, she tried to, but Julia's sister put her in her place.
I think my delema is with Julia, I just don't like the girl. (or her family)
I still think Kim will continue to improve but I'm sure there will be someone else that has yet to be seen that will grab me like Kelly and Tamyra did last year.
Welcome aboard Pantageas

Goddessatlaw

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 04:08 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Ooh, Pantageas, FABULOUS first post, although I didn't see the show and have no position on the Kimberly/Julia problem. You're going to be fun to have around. Isn't there a 1/2 hour show tonight? Gotta go look at Ryn's TV thread.

Car54

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 04:25 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Good catch Pantageas, but I tend to agree with Webkitty... faced with Julia's passive agressive martyrdom, I would do a lot more than stick my tongue out.

For my money Kimberly is the closest thing to the whole package we have seen so far (not saying much with the group she is in). I did not see anything objectionable last night in her red room behavior either.

I will be interested to see her advance and have to go up against some of the better singers who are now in other groups. It is hard to say how she will do. Honestly, except for Frenchie and Kimberly Locke and a couple of the men, I can't really recall many others.

Pantageas

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 04:35 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Thanks for the welcome everone. BTW Webkitty, remember this is supposedly the first meeting of the "Duelin' Divas" that day! . Julia couldn't get ahold of any of the girls after dinner. She finally meets them when she goes upstairs(duh!). Fast forward to the next day. Julia purposely waits to make a late "diva" entrance. Kimberly C. basically declines(speaking on behalf of the other girls, too) to practice with her, then does the making faces/laughing thing behind Julia's back(but luckily for us, in FRONT of the camera!!). :)

Julia's sister hasn't even gotten involved yet! That response is all about Kimberly!! I think it does show that she has the capacity to be catty. A bigger person would have diffused the situation right there, rather than thrown gasoline on it!

Anyhow, please don't think I'm favoring one over the other. I think they both have some growing up to do. I can't wait to see their responses on tonight's show, though! After all, I don't think both of them will advance(though I'm sure Simon will make sure the loser gets an "at-large" spot)...

Goddessatlaw

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 04:37 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Speaking of which - I'll go start tonight's thread. By the way - maybe we should just start one thread for each week until things get down to the wire.

Hermione69

Wednesday, February 05, 2003 - 04:38 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Why do we even have to take sides? I didn't see it and I don't have a VCR to rewatch it, but I think they were both probably wrong. Besides, no matter how someone behaves to you, sticking your tongue out at that person behind their back (especially when a camera is trained on you!) is childish and catty. My co-librarian does stuff like that to people and trust me, no matter how justified, it's tacky and graceless. We all cringe every time she does it. OMG, I am getting out of here, LOL! Neither of them deserve that much of my energy! I hope they both get knocked off!

Go Clay!

Adven

Thursday, February 06, 2003 - 04:33 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Thanks for the heads up on the Millionaire thread, Wink. I am an ardent admirer of the female form, for esthetic reasons only, of course, so I may head over or take in an episode or two. I am writing a scholarly treatise, complete with pictures, on the female breast, so this could come in handy. If I can't get enough material, I may just turn it into one of those pop-up picture books.

Weenerlobo

Thursday, February 06, 2003 - 06:11 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Hermione - yep, I did mean Meosha. OOOPS!

Kizz

Monday, February 10, 2003 - 03:14 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Car, I know I'm coming back a little late with this response concerning your comment about Kelly's attire last time, but I had to remind you about the dress she wore during the Big Band week. I thought she looked like a doll, hair was wonderful as well. To me, she looked like they pulled her right out of a USO canteen.

Car54

Monday, February 10, 2003 - 04:10 pm EditMoveDeleteIP
Kizz, I didn't see that one. I only saw the auditions and the finals.

She looks a LOT better lately.

I can see where that style would suit her tho!