Archive through September 11, 2003
TV ClubHouse: Archive: Hypothetical: Allison vs. Robert for final 2, who would you vote for?:
Archive through September 11, 2003
Earthmother | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 08:46 am     I agree Pengoh..if you lose at the end due to your behavior inside the house then you have not played the best game. |
Spunky | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 10:36 am     Oh boy, how I changed my mind!! Robert!! ( I still cannot believe myself!!) |
Kalekona | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:01 am     Gina8642 - you may not think Robert is playing the game but he is.. and his "so called allience" that was just buddys he could hang out with.. well he's in the F3 and they are basking on the beach. Ali didn't play the best game.. remember Hardy won repeatedly but didn't play the game well and was booted... Ali failed to think about the jury. Jun played the best game. But to say Robert didn't play at all just floated is simply your opinion, he did something right to be the last guy AND the last eX standing.. |
Cliotheleo | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:06 am     And once again let me point out that the jury votes haven't been cast yet. The reason why Robert's still in the house is that unlike Justin and Jee (and Erika and Nate and even Jack) is that he's not a threat. Again, not because he's TRYING to to be a threat ....... he's just there, not being a threat. |
Volgirl | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:08 am     Robert 1st choice Jun 2nd and it would be hiliarious to see Ali leave at this point. |
Squidward | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:28 am     Without a doubt, ROBERT. He had a target on his back for just walking in the door as an ex. Ali would be long gone if not for the gullible Nate. |
Elle | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:29 am     robert - i can't believe i just typed his name! |
Stingerman | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:35 am     Lesser of 2 evils would be Robert |
Gina8642 | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 11:56 am     Kale - the question was - who would you vote for. so I answered and clearly stated that it was my opinion. You attack my post and say it is wrong. Everyone can say how they would vote, but my opinion is just that - my opinion. Because it is my opinion it cannot be wrong for me. Someone else's opinion can be different - but don't tell me I can't have my opinion. Or my vote should be your vote. So, please don't attack my opinion - state yours. Mine is allowed to differ. |
Bbfanatic | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 12:10 pm     i agree with your opinion gina. i would pick ali also. i think she played the best game |
Gidget | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 12:18 pm     Robert. |
Sunshyne4u | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 12:51 pm     I honor your opinions here. Many have said they would vote Robert and listed their reasons. However, I take GREAT exception to the posters who keep saying "it is for his daughter". Many times on Live Feeds he has made it clear what he wants to do with the money, and believe me, it has NOTHING to do with his daughter or her future needs. A second Rolex and a Porsche. This was repeated by Robert multiple times on Feeds and also shown on the Television show. He got to where he is(in my opinion)by "swearing on his daughter" that he was telling the truth when making shady deals with people. He talked rarely about his daughter to the other HGs, more about all the Sl*ts and Wh*res he parties with outside of the house and how all they want is a big bang. Then he offers Viagra to the young guys he is bragging to. Robert might be fooling you guys now........but remember him a couple of weeks ago. I really dont want him to win any money as he has already said most will be blown in Vegas. |
Earthmother | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 01:29 pm     First of all how he spends the money is no ones damn business. I have not heard anyone say that he should win because of his daughter, only that he should win because he has proven himself to be more of a man than he has shown in the game by proving his decency as a father. Personally I find that skill just as important in winning as the one who stood on the dog house longer, if you happen to get to the final 2. There are a lot of components to this game and gettting the final votes from the jury is a biggy, even if you never won a single competition...(Dani) |
Katlady53 | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 01:34 pm     I agree, Earthmother. I don't think it's anyone's business how ANY of the HG's would spend the money. Nor do I want Robert to win because of his daughter. He's simply the lesser of three evils to me right now. I never dreamed I would actually want him to win the money, but when given the choices we have at the moment, I want him to have the dough. |
Surreal_Badger | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 01:52 pm     ali or robert -- what an awful choice. my two least favorite players. on the first evening of the show, i pegged robert (and jun, but that's a different thread) as a hg that i thought would win. he struck me as the type of man who could play up the "charm" and win women's affections at the same time as not appearing a big physical threat to the other wannabe alpha males. of course, after getting to know robert a little better over these past months, he was one of the first hg's i wished would GO. he seemed so clueless -- the lies, the posturing, the picking. and i just can't forgive him for the awful words that came out of his mouth about women. sorry. i don't care how hard BB has tried to portray him as a "good father" (what a tearjerker that last AC was, eh?!?!?) or play-up he and erika's mending fences. i know "deserving" is a subjective evaluation--and we'll all probably disagree as to what constitutes it--but i just don't see that robert "deserves" this. don't get me wrong. i don't like ali at all. but she'd get my vote. she played the game (or her version of it, at least) HARD and successfully. robert on the other hand -- what were his great maneuvers: trying twice (and failing twice) to get erika evicted? last week's alliance with erika that (IMHO) led to her eviction? low-balling his "math" in the HOH comp? puh-lease give ali some credit! |
Earthmother | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 01:59 pm     Ali only played successfully if in the end she walks out with the big prize. I think she successfully played one aspect of this game, while damaging herself severly on the other side. The trick is to get to the final 2 without destroying your chance of winning because you failed to behave humanly. |
Sherri | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 02:30 pm     I'd vote for Robert, ONLY because he irritates me less than Ali. No other reason. Nothing about how they played or didn't play the game. Purely emotional, but it is what I would do at this point. I'd also vote for Robert over Jun at this point. Same reason. Go figure |
Csnog | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 04:56 pm     I'm voting for Jun even though you want me to decide between Ali and Robert. If Ali and Robert are left I abstain! LOL |
Twiggyish | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 05:06 pm     Robert..the lesser of the two evils. |
Nadi | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 05:30 pm     Coming out of lurkdom to post... I'd vote for Ali. I couldn't stand Ali when the game started, but I do think she has played the hardest. I also think she's a harmless twit. I think most of what comes out of her mouth, and the behaviour she has exhibited in the house has been for the most part a big act. I don't really hear any genuine malice in her words when she says "I hate so and so". On the other hand I do hear degradation and hostility when Robert uses words like sl**s and wh***s and I find it disturbing when people defend Robert with the argument that he loves his daughter, is a good father etc. Despite what we see on TV most men are good fathers. Loving your child is not a commendable trait. It's natural. It's the bare minimum. There are plenty of despicable people who love their own children. The commendable thing is being a good role model for your child. Setting a positive example and shaping your child's self image through your actions and words. Parents are the most influential people to a child. Children learn their value system from their parents. What do you think it does to a child when she hears her father refer to women as sl**s and wh***s? To hear that he uses them and treats them as sex objects for his own gratification. |
Earthmother | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 05:38 pm     Ali used herself as a sex object for more than one guy in that house, and as a woman that bothers me more than some frat boy calling girls names. Irregardless of whether she means it or not I don't find that commendable enough to want her to win. The bottom line is will she win? It's up to the jury. It doesn't really matter what either of them say except to the people they are saying it about..Who has said and done the most hurtfull things about the sequestered will be the determining factor as to who will win this game. |
Tabbyking | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 05:51 pm     they are both scum...i could not vote. i'd lose my stipend. oh crap...for the stipend only.... shudders as if seeing a tarantula, ROBERT, only because ali is worse. runs to wash bad taste out of mouth.... |
Windella | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 06:05 pm     do i really have to say???? jack left ages ago, and i wanted him to win. but to decide between robert and ali? i can't believe i'm going to say this, so i'll whisper, ali. don't tell my boyfriend he'll have me committed. she played everybody in this game. she never had a true alliance, she picked sides as the mood hit her. but she's made a lot of enemies. she played hard. i can't stand her personally, but i dislike robert also. between the 3, (but that's not the question, sorry) i'd take jun. |
Mlt | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 06:24 pm     I think I've come up with an ending that I would consider satisfactory if Ali and Robert are the final two. First, they have the houseguests vote and reveal the winner. Then they say: 'But there is one final twist. We aren't paying out any money this year. You have both won exactly NOTHING.' It would be fun seeing their reactions. |
Sunshyne4u | Thursday, September 11, 2003 - 07:03 pm     well said, Nadi Earth and Kat "I have not heard anyone say that he should win because of his daughter, only that he should win" ***** A couple of previous posters said he SHOULD win because of being a father and they would vote FOR HIS daughter.....It is written clearly in previous posts. Please dont slam me personally for stating my opinion after reading those comments. Thx It has been discussed by quite a few posters in this thread WHY and WHO they would want to win...the money issue and how it would be spent has been raised a number of times, not just by myself. |
|