Archive through July 25, 2003
MoveCloseDeleteAdmin

TV ClubHouse: Archives: Big Brother 4 General Discussion Archives through July 28: Rate the Houseguests in Order you Like Them: Archive through July 25, 2003

Maryk

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 07:38 am EditMoveDeleteIP
We did this in the past seasons, its been several weeks now... so just for fun, lets order the houseguests in the order we like/dislike them:

9999. Robert - everytime I see him I want to throw up.
9. Dana - her voice/attitude irritates me to no end.
8. Jee - he is a puppet and when he had the power he completely turned me off.
7. Alison - annoying.
6. Nate - I really wanted to like him but then he opened his mouth.
5. Justin - if only he wasn't aligned with the stooges
4. Jun - playing a good game, respect that.
3. Erica - would rate higher if not for the comment.
2. Jack - good guy, just a tad boring.
1. Dave - doesn't take himself seriously and is playing a good game.

Jagger

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 07:58 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10 Jee, he needs to make a decision on his own and learn how this game is played.
9 Robert, he is too h#llbent on getting Erica out of the house to play a decent game.
8 Jun, she just plan irritates me
7 Ali, nice to look at but nothing else there.
6 Erica she really hasn't come out yet, seems she gets upset and cries too easily.
5 Nathon, he's a pretty boy but has no character as of yet.
4 Jack, Didn't like him at first but liking him more and more every day
3 Justin, I think he is playing a good game so far, he knows what he is doing and hopefully will continue on with his game plan.
2 Dana, she really seems to shake the house up and is totally unpredictable
1 Dave, he is the group clown, but knows exactly what he is doing.

Spwisc

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:03 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Jee - Ok, I think he's cute!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and no one expects him to win!
2. Justin - Cute and playing the game
3. Jun - because she's playing both sides
4. Dave - He could've treated Michelle better
5. Dana - Like the crazy personality & she's tough, I'd like to see her do some karate on the person of her choice!
6. Jack - Cool guy but boring
7. Nate - He's no Josh from BB1 but he's trying
8. Robert - Just because
9. Erika - The racial comment was cruel
10. Alison - Too mean to Justin for no reason, snotty attitude.

Dke1212

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:03 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Nate - pretty boy, <LC>
9. Alison - whiney wannabe princess
8. David - thinks he's big comedian, (not)
7. Robert - just because
6. Erica - mean and nasty comments
5. Jack - still kind of neutral on him
4. Justin - just like him more than previous 6
3. Jee - not as big a puppet as some may think
2. Dana - not afraid to tell people what she really thinks which is refreshing in this game, and is first HOH to do what should be done when nominating, no real decoy, either could go and would be fine
1. Jun - has just played the best all around game

Catkey94

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:06 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Dana
9. Robert
8. Jun
7. Nate
6. Justin
5. Alison
4. Jee
3. Erika
2. Jack
1. David

Mranon

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:07 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Dana - She has no clue. She can't win and she doesn't even know that
9. Robert - Used Vacuum Cleaner Salesman is more like it.
8. Justin - Could be a much better player, but has no clue what he is doing.
7. Jun - Disgusting eating habits, chewing with her mouth open. Plays well though.
6. Ali - The world does NOT revolve around you!
5. Jee - "I gave my life for this house!" 'nuff said.
4. Erica - She went from nice and quiet to annoying and annoying.
3. Nate - Goooooolllly you are silly to think you might be the smartest person in the house.
2. Jack - Boring but nice. Stooping to other's levels though isn't going to help him.
1. Dave - Plays very well, funny as all heck and enjoys life.

Llkoolaid

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:11 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10: Dana
9: Robert
8: Jun
7: Nate
6: Alison
5: Jee
4: Justin
3: Jack
2: David
1: Erika

Sasman

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:14 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Jee - <LC>
9. Robert - ugly person
8. Jun - playing game well but she annoys me
7. Nate - too full of himself
6. Ali - too full of herself
5. Justin - can't understand his game
4. Erica - too nice for this house
3. Dana - smart, playing well; too paranoid
2. Jack - smart to lay low; very intelligent
1. Dave - doesn't take things too seriously, just makes me laugh a lot which is unique in this house

Jmh1971

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:14 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Jack- great guy but needs to start playing
2. Dave- Funny as hell
3. Erica- Needs to watch what she says
4. Jee- He's getting played by Justin and Robert
5. Nate- an idiot if he wins Veto and uses it
6. Ali- No comment
7. Jun- No one cares you're a tease
8. Justin- Needs to get a clue. Dana won't help him
9. Robert- Too bad he wasn't in the tub with the toaster
10. Dana- Why does she make threats about people and get to stay? When Scott did it he was booted?

Juki58

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:17 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. David - Dosen't take this all that serious.
2. Jack - A real nice guy.
3. Nate - Cause i was born in OK. hee hee
4. Erika - Good player.
5. Jun - She cracks me up.
6. Ali - Only because I want her before the other ones on my list.
7. Jee - A ok guy
8. Justin - <LC>.
9. Dana - <LC>.
10. Robert - <LC>.

Anneph

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:21 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Robert - mean spirited
9. Jee - puppet - no spine
8. Dana - crass, potty mouth
7. Nat - wussy, pretty boy
6. Jun - just plain annoying
5. Justin - got stuck with wrong alliance
4. Alison - amazing memory
3. Erika - nice girl
2. Jack - playing smart, sharp
1. Dave - hope he goes all the way

Redstar

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:27 am EditMoveDeleteIP
Wow! This was hard! Unlike in past seasons, there's no one that I really like and root for. So I based my picks on who provides the most potential long-term drama and entertainment.

10. Robert - one dimensional - "get Erika" is already old.
9. Jee - when he's not HOH, he's invisible
8. Nate - just plain boring
7. Erika - not living up to potential with Robert still in the house
6. Jack - too analytical, not enough emotion
5. Justin - there's potential for more once a few more hamsters are out
4. Ali - her little crown has been knocked akew with this nomination and she is picking up steam
3. Jun - devious is always good
2. Dave - player AND funny - good entertainment combo
1. Dana - she could almost be as fun to watch melt down as Nicole was

Naja

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:30 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Erika (in my eyes, she is a skinnier me, and I like me..lol)
2. David (Very fun guy)
3. Jack (I like older men, and he is a good, smart, dependable one)
4. Justin (very good-looking, but he spoiled it for me by playing rub rub with UGH UGH (Dana)
5. Jun
6. Ali
7. Nate
8. Robert
9. Jee
10. Dana (as much as I like a ruckus happening in the BB house and truly appreciate her creating one, I can't take her mouth being on auto-pilot 24/7)

Bmh

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:31 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10.Robert-This guy is an <LC>, a <LC>...I just hate him...And very harsh
9.Dana-Pyscho woman. She is a <LC> nuff said
8.Jee-he is a friggin puppet used by everybody
7.Nathan-Thinks he is so above everybody else,really <LC>
6.Justin-not a bad guy,giving,logical, but in wrong alliance
5.Alison-Whiney,snooby, yet she has grown on me and I pity the girl..Win that Veto!
4.Jack-Nice,intelligent,but clueless and boring
3.Erika-beautiful,nice,and really starting to play the game
2.Dave-funny,Tries to make all situations light and enjoyable..A real "good guy" at heart
1.Jun-I love my Jun! Her bitchy comments are hilarious and She is playing a excellent game so far..but it is catching up with her because unfortunately she just choose the wrong side to align with.

Maris

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:31 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1, Justin
2. Jee
3. Jun
4. Dana
5-9, the rest of them.

Bigfan

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:32 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Robert-He's unlikeable in the house and I would guess he is unlikeable in the real world.

9. Dana-This girls head is spinning around like a search light!

8. Dave- he comes off sad to me, not funny.

7. Allison- she has been the belle of the ball so many times that doen't realize that her actions make her an ugly duckling.

6. Justin- if he stays away from Dana and Robert, he could fly under the radar.

5. Jack- the quieter he stays, the better he plays.

4. Erica- I think she knows the game better than anyone but has let her past hurts shut her down.

3. Jee- is to much of a follower for his own good but basically a good person.

2. Jun- playing a good game, working both sides, cooking, cleaning and when she keeps her hateful mouth shut plays the best game.

1. Nathan- When he plays the GAME, he plays a good game, when he PLAYS, he plays a bad game.

I will say this year, I have not really found a favorite and kept a favorite so my top 10 could change before the day is over. Oh heck, it could change before noon!

Srobb22

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:33 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Nate - I find him to be petty, small-minded, & increasingly ignorant.
9. Alison - She is so whiny & annoying.
8. Robert - He is a jerk!
7. Erica - I intensely disliked the way she belittle Jee & now Dana
6. Jack - I simply find him uninteresting.
5. Jee - He does not seem to have a mind of his own but he is rather entertaining.
4. Dana - I used to find her really annoying - she is like a caricature - but since she turned on the original alliance, she has been rather amusing.
3. Dave - He is always quite amusing!
2. Jun - I adore her. She is like a real woman - not skinny or a perfect body and she is funny and plays the game well!
1. Justin - He is so gorgeous and also plays the game well.

Goddessatlaw

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:36 am EditMoveDeleteIP
They all get a big donut hole from me so far - I can't even find anyone to truly despise, much less truly like. I'm going to have to hold out for another week or so and see if anyone crops up with a personality before placing an order on things.

Jan

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:37 am EditMoveDeleteIP
well I see a trend starting here..a high percentage of Jack and David in top two and Dana and robert in last two..For me, today anyway, it is as follows (who knows how I will feel tomorrow):

1. Jack good clean play..quiet but strategizing
2. Dave does not take himself or game seriously
3. Erica hates Rob but never badmouthed him, strategizing well
4. Jun master strategist but not very likeable.
but I don't mind if one of these 4 wins..as for the rest, I really DO NOT WANT THEM TO WIN

5.alison not as bad as the rest but really using touchy/feely to try to manipulate
6. Nate loves himself too much.doesn't need my adulation (and hasn't got it)..
7.dana wacko jocko
8. justin using dana ..is maybe not as bad as I thought. may move up for me
9jee..has no idea..just a puppet
10 robert.."he is the devil" as Dani would say

edited to add: well a trend was starting when I began my post. By the time I finished my post, the added threads destroyed the trend!I am such a slow typist!

Weinermr

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:46 am EditMoveDeleteIP
10. Robert
9. Jun
8. Dana
7 and 6. Jee and Nate, Nate and Jee
5. Allison
4. Justin
3 and 2. Jack and Erika, Erika and Jack
1. Dave

Bohawkins

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 08:53 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. Dana is the best. She is articulate and fun to listen to. I like smart women.
2. Dave. Funny and likable.
3. Jun - clever and not taken in by anyone.
4. Jee - a nice fellow... not too bright.
5. Robert - quite the salesman.
6. Justin - he seems slow, but he was smart enough to align with the power woman.
7. Erika - nothing to dislike about her, just not impressive in the game.
8. Jack - he is a con man's con man. But, he couldn't fool Dana.
9-10. Nathan, Allison - just plain self absorbed and not very smart. They make southerners look bad.

Lurknomore

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 09:06 am EditMoveDeleteIP
LOL if you read all the reasons in all the threads someone has made my list BUT no one did it all together lol. So here goes, with a couple tweaks.

10 and 9)--TIE for most annoying/disliked. How can one choose between Dana and Robert. Both get on my last nerve and I'm grateful I don't know either of them in RL lol.

8)Alison--Few redeeming qualities, shares Dana and Jun's way of alliance hopping but without adding much of anything but the aforementioned whining.

7)Jee--He would have been higher pre his HoH Nepolean complex. A week worth of his delusional strutting around was enough to have me sit here and decide if he or Ali annoyed me more. She won, but not by much.

6)Jun--Although I think she may be playing one of the better games, I just can't stand her or her repeated prejudicial comments and CONSTANT eating.

5) Erika--like someone said she would have been higher if it wasn't for HER prejudicial comments. Also I haven't seen her add much to the game.

4)Nate--I think he's smarter than some thing and is just used to being a big fish in a small pond. If he was a little bit older and had learned a tad more I think he would have matured past some of the ego we always see. But I don't think he's that bad and he seems to have shown respect and loyalty to Jack.

3) Justin--I like him. He seems like a stand up guy who just, in desperation, aligned himself with 2 wrong guys. I haven't seen him be mean to anyone. Wish he'd show more personality but I can say that for everyone I'm posting about.

2) Jack--major plus, he's not in his 20's. He's smarter than he's letting on and trying to play low key right now. I am PRAYING as the game goes on if he can hang in there he will emerge and really show us his stuff. He deserves to win something for managing to live with most of these (oh what word won't be moderated dang this is hard lol), um, hmmmmm, well you all know what I mean /clipart{wink}

TADA:
1) DAVE! Funny how he is at or near the top of almost all lists. Maybe cause he is the ONLY one who has shown any personality and tried to make it fun. Plus I also think he is a lot smarter than he has shown. He's cute and fun and I like him!

Idolworship

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 09:16 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. The Turtles (really laid back players)
2. Dave (all personality, ala "Dr. Evil")
3. Jack (seemingly a nice guy)
4. Erica (giving her the benefit of the doubt,
here.)
5. The others, who are just annoying!

Prisonerno6

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 09:23 am EditMoveDeleteIP
The only one I like without reservation so far is Jack, and I would really like him to win.

Dave and Erika are tied as far as likability. Dave gets points for being entertaining, intelligent, and playing the game well, but he loses me with the homophobic comments. I like the way Erika has handled herself in a very difficult situation, but I don't think we're really getting to see her real personality because of Robert being there. However, I find these two, along with Jack, innately trustworthy, which makes them much more likable than the others in my book.

I'm neutral on Jun and Justin. Jun gets very big plus points for the way she plays the game, but she gets very big minus points for the pettiness she shows towards the others. Justin is just flying under the radar too much for me to decide one way or the other with him. Time will tell.

I actively dislike Robert, Jee, Dana, Nate and Ali, all for the small-minded narcissism, racism, homophobia and classism they've shown. Unfortunately, if Dana gets her way this week, it looks like one of them will actually win it. If that becomes more certain, I think it will spell the end of my watching BB4.

Polypody

Friday, July 25, 2003 - 09:26 am EditMoveDeleteIP
1. David
2. Erica
3. Jack
4. Ali
5. Jee
6. Nate
7. Justin
8. Dana
9. Robert
10. Jun