Archive through September 17, 2002
TV ClubHouse: Archives: Which was better, BB1, BB2, or BB3?:
Archive through September 17, 2002
Ocean_Islands | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:23 pm     The jury is still out. However the remaining houseguests are so much nicer this year than those remaining at this point last year, that it's got to be looking up. But which BB was the best so far? |
Webrover99 | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:31 pm     I will always like BB1 best because it was pure. Most of the houseguests didn't seem to come in with this big plan to win. I think that people were there more for the experience and to have fun. After that it has become more and more contrived. |
Jagger | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:36 pm     BB1 was the best probably because it was the first one. In that one the fans picked who got booted, so there was no strategizing, it was just a bunch of people trying to survive in a house. BB controled these people much better than they have this group or last years group. This year was more entertaining to me than last years group. |
Battlestar | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:39 pm     The end of last year was more interesting then this one....unless Lisa or Amy wins HOH (3 to 1 odds on this one), the rest of BB will just be hanging out |
Dagny | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:39 pm     This year is way better then last year.. Does it beat BB1? I don't know..can't decide. |
Secretsmile | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:42 pm     There were alot of things in BB1 that I wish weren't lost. #1 I enjoyed the people working for their perks. The competitions were days long and entertaining. #2 There were less FOTH moments, I mean do we really have to be blocked from hearing, Good Morning Houseguests? #3 The hg's weren't 'casted' The people were real, they had more of a real feeling to them. To me BB2 was a huge disappointment. There wasn't any one that was't anyone that wasn't "ON" all the time. BB3 is entertaining but I still feel it's too casted Lisa keeps calling them 'the cast' and it's hard for me to really care about them as people. #1 I do think penality nominations should have been used. I am actually sickened by the continued character assinations, each of the hg's have families and they are affected, unfairly. It may be a game, but the families aran't the ones playing. #2 The competitions are more imaginitive than in BB2. #3 The show seems to be truer to the live feeds than in BB2 I expect that BB4 will be the best one yet, since I've made these recommendations and I'm sure A.S. was just waiting to hear my views! ROFLMAO |
Costacat | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:43 pm     BB1, definitely! They had to work ever so much harder on just living (the garden! the chickens! the potato clock!). Since it was also the first one, none of the contestants knew what to expect. So there was much less strategizing or game-playing or whatever. As far as STRESS levels from watching, I think BB2 and BB3 are a tie. I haven't really liked as many of the contestants on BB3 as I did on BB2. Some of 'em are a little hard to relate to, y'know? But the STRESS of waiting for Roddy to get evicted added about a dozen new gray hairs on my poor head! <grin> |
Cmore | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:44 pm     BB2 blows this year away so far. The remaining HG's this year are.......well.....just plain boring to watch. |
Bmh | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:52 pm     BB1 sucked BB2..was better..the only real entertainment that season was Will..sorry I dont find watchin some psycho (Nicole) about to break down interesting BB3..rules!!!..such an improvement from last year..this year has just been more entertaining |
Aerojunki | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:52 pm     I'd have to say BB1..But I liked all 3 seasons & I'll be there for the next!  |
Muse | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:53 pm     I'm really enjoying BB3 right now (which is a nice surprise, since I really had my doubts about the show the first few weeks - I didn't care for the six pack at all). But overall, I'd have to say BB2 was better. The final four was an interesting combination, and of course Will added a lot of humor. Nicole's meltdown during the last few weeks was pretty dramatic, too. I liked BB1 and was definitely addicted, but I didn't find it nearly as interesting as the second and third seasons. Nice people (well, most of them), but not enough drama. |
Tippet | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 02:56 pm     BB1 was my favorite by far, I loved the people, loved the week long challenges, loved everything about it. BB2 was better then this year for me tho, I liked the people more I guess. This year instead of who I like, it's more who do I dislike the least |
Whit4you | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:01 pm     The OZ BB was by far the best one to me but since it's not an optin here... All 3 BB's were "the best" in a different way. I guess I'd pick BB 2 - because I don't MISS BB 1 and definately won't MISS BB 3. But I do miss BB 2 - Will and his antics. |
Battlestar | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:04 pm     I hope Arnold starts using penalties in some form or another next year--each year should have something different and strict enforcement of rules would add to the stress for the HG |
Onlyhuman | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:04 pm     I think it depends if you are talking live feeds or television show... Live Feeds BB1 was the greatest. We saw so much more than we see now. Dawn barbecues, "You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling" on the kitchen table, the BB bedtime story, the proposed walkout...it was AMAZING! And it was all free! I don't mind paying for the live feeds, but I have been disappointed by the overuse of FOTH in both BB2 & BB3. I would have to give the BB2 live feeds 2nd place, only because we seemed to see just a little bit more and because there was a little more drama towards the end. Television Show This is a tough one. The BB2 has the edge in personalities (who can forget Will's DR antics?) but the production on BB3, along with the improved contests makes it a strong contender. Personally, I'd say BB2 wins by a small margin, simply because Will made watching the show a must, but I don't feel that way for BB3. The BB1 television show stunk. |
Keiffer | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:05 pm     BB1's first night was better because we got to see the HG's from the moment they entered the house live. BB2's last week or two was better because of the way Will kept picking on Nicole, and Nicole always being one stray word away from a real breakdown. BB3 was the best in between. |
Victoriafla | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:14 pm     For me BB2 was my favorite and gave me lots of laughs. |
Whit4you | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:16 pm     Oh well when it comes to the tv show - this year is hands down the best (in my opinion) |
Bbfanatic | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:17 pm     i like the live shows much better in bb1. like i recently put in another thread. i love the live audience and all of the commotion outside when the hgs were evicted. i like how the remaining hgs would go to the backyard and listen to the people outside screaming when someone was evicted. they thought they were such celebs. i like how the evicted hg could see the tv screens showing the remaining hgs in the house during the live eviction show. i also like how the bb1 hgs arrived in suvs and walked up the sidewalk past their families and friends. i would rather not know who the hgs are until they enter the house. i also loved the bb1 dance marathon. |
Aerojunki | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:17 pm     My best BB moment was with BB1, when Josh got drunk & done his little dance with the broom. I still laugh thinking about it! Wish I still had the video clip. |
Csnog | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:30 pm     I would like to see a combination of the 3 BB years. Make them work for perks. Banners would be OK because they confuse the HG's. Penality Nominations or points toward nominations for attacking other HG family's or derogatory remarks that could loose a persons job. I don't want to see this get out of hand next year. Less FOTH. Find some music they can sing. Give them a decent PET, even chickens are better than lizzards. |
Wcv63 | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:34 pm     I like something about all 3 shows. The novelty of BB1 got me hooked. The drama of BB2 kept me hooked. And the strategizing of BB3 was OFF THE HOOK!! |
Aerojunki | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:35 pm     Next year would be a trip if they put all the people together from the last 3 years..that would be a riot! |
Lynnann | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:37 pm     Bb2 has to be the winner. You had Will's wonderful humor, Nicole's insanity and we all loved watching her lose because she was so sure of herself. The only thing I was disappointed in was when they took Justin off. Right about now we could use him in BB3- I would love to see old Jason quaking in his shoes as Justin walks through the room and Dani trying to figure out how to approach him- too funny. |
Curlyq | Tuesday, September 17, 2002 - 03:46 pm     Tough question. I liked BB2 enough to get extremely addicted to the drama, but I liked BB1 enough to want to watch BB2. I also liked the free feeds and the fact that not spending every moment plotting left the HGs more time to be themselves and get a little silly. The BB1 cast were more like people I'd be happy to get to know in real life, the BB2 HGs were people I was happy to watch play the game, and for the most part the BB3 HGs are people I wouldn't want to know in the game or in real life. |
|