Archive through August 29, 2002
TV ClubHouse: Archive: Is BB really so stupid that they didn't realize Lisa's farewell message was a major diss to Gerry?:
Archive through August 29, 2002
Moondance | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:10 pm     Thank you Wcv! Exactly!! BTW if I remember right there were a few simi not so nice nice messages in the previous BBs. |
Sunlit | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:12 pm     I thought Marc said goodbye, a sort of monotone "go back to your wife, your job" Am I imagining things? lol |
Cajunrambler | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:13 pm     Sherbabe, I do recall Marcellus wishing him well. |
Jasonfan | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:19 pm     I want to give Lisa the benefit of the doubt. She's usually pretty positive and somewhat sensitive in the diary room. I would be curious to hear what she said about Gerry around the statement that aired. Realistically, last week BB could have edited her "but I still love you" to C and she would have seemed catty. Perhaps the snippet that was aired was just a small part of her goodbye. Sunlit-- I agree. M was careful, I think, to not be negative but also to not encourage any ideas of friendship from G. |
Maris | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:21 pm     I had some company over as we watched BB, our eviction ritual and we all just went HUH???? with Lisas goodbye. I still havent figured it out. |
Sybilbb3oracle | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:23 pm     Lisa said that she was going to turn into a mean bi*ch; she has, but in a very cowardness (Shannon sp?) way. CBS should have deleted it even if she did intend for that to be a cruel message. Lisa is being sighted as the big winner by more than one website; she shouldn't count on Gerry's vote, even if its just Lisa and Amy as the final two. |
Screeminmeemie | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 08:30 pm     It's plain to see the HG's don't love each other to death. That's evident from DR entries and the live feeds. However, CBS is supposed to be neutral in their treatment of the HG's. They certainly have the option to be kind in the exit interview. Since the evicted HG has a loved one to meet them, there is absolutely no good reason to air a negative goodbye on national tv and have the family members see and hear it. Publicly humiliating a person on a live broadcast has no good tv value. It made me feel really badly for Gerry and very angry at CBS. |
Lyn | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 09:15 pm     I was surprised that BB3 would show a negative message in the goodbyes. I'm not quite sure what Lisa meant but there's no getting around that it didn't SOUND very nice. |
Ryn | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 09:26 pm     Lisa simply meant she wished she had been the one to put him up for eviction as revenge for GErry putting her and Eric up. I was surprised as well, I think thats the 1st time they have shown a negative comment in the "farewells," but Gerry didn't seem to mind, I'm over it........time to move on. |
Beagle | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 09:28 pm     I just finished watching the show. I was shocked to hear those parting words by Lisa. Why in the world would CBS leave something like that in there? Gerry is going to be subject to enough heartbreak when he sees what they really think of him. I felt very badly for that man tonight and have for quite some time. Does anyone know or have a guess why Gerry's wife didn't come on the show? If this is being discused somewhere else, point me in that general direction.
 |
Whit4you | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 09:36 pm     Well my 2 cents - I believe she had a right to say what she said but it should have been said or at least shown during her voting process (and it was probably said during her voting process but they wanted to show it separately for 'effect') My roommate (who's not a net person at all and knows very little of what we see) was shocked when they showed that - I actually thought I misunderstood - looked at him and he was shaking his head - eyes wide. He thought the same thing as me - that was totally uncalled for and tacky. I don't really think HER saying it was uncalled for and tacky - but BB playing it for someone who just got evicted? The right thing for BB to have done is leave off say Marc and Lisa's "fairwell' messages - so it didn't look so obvious that Lisa's was not there. But the thing is the last few times it was obvious to me who's messages were nto there and it didn't matter. I'll say this though - from BB's standpoint as wrong as it was for Gerry - it was 'good tv' for those who don't know all the nasty bashing they do to him that we all know. Sigh. Hate that they did it though. I hope Gerry does find out how much support he's had out here. |
Angelsluv | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 09:45 pm     K, now what's this thread have to do with the producers hating Gerry ??? It's the producers always making Gerry look bad, and not just Lisa's "good bye" to Gerry.. **Confused about the Moderator's moving "The Producers hated Gerry too!!!" to this thread** |
Earthmother | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:13 pm     I just think the worst part of this whole show has been the avoidance of the HOH, and why? When you win the HOH you are put in the position Gerry was put in. Everyone coming to him "break up the couples, break up the couples", makes sense to him, heck it made sense to all of us. He does it and everyone except Lisa and Eric are happy about it, finally it breaks down the large allience. This is the first time nominees are treated like royalty..everyone is happy, happy. Then the vote comes down to a tie since no guts from the POV so Gerry decides to tumble Roddy by getting rid of Eric (now isn't Roddy the one that they all wanted to lose his allience?) just trying to remember back. Now Gerry has done what Dani asked and kept her girl and deflated the Rod man. Then for the next 3 weeks he is villified by the same people he saved and the excuse for it "he made a deal with Roddy to save his own sorry ass.." and his reward for keeping Lisa is that she disses him on national tv while he is already down. Are they playing a game for money or not? Is it any wonder no one wants to win these competiions? There needs to either be another way for nominations, maybe like in the first show and then let them vote collectively. The HOH has done nothing but turn this into a game of revenge. |
Rig | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:18 pm     When I heard that, I thought "WHAT A LITTLE B****!" As long as I'm ranting, I don't see why people think Lisa is so attractive. IMO, she doesn't have a pretty face, is too skinny, has a tempermental personality, and is promiscuous. She is not one of the "good people". I think her saying something nasty was entirely within character. |
Bb3friend | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:19 pm     The nerve of Lisa. That was a cheap shot and it shows just what a coward she really is. |
Willsfan | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:31 pm     I was watching with other people too and we were all surprised by BB's decision to air Lisa's message. BTW, at the beginning of the show didn't marcellas say if they had voted out people based on how ugly they were Gerry would have been the first to go? Or was he referring to himself? |
Serena | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:39 pm     1. There's no unwritten rule that the 'goodbye' video montage HAS TO be positive. I had no such expectation. 2. When, for example, Mike Boogie or Shannon was evicted, I would have WANTED to see remaining houseguests saying, "I'm GLAD you're gone. You're a jerk." Even if Gerry doesn't deserve it, any houseguest leaving should have to take the good with the bad. 3. Lisa's message to Gerry will WORK AGAINST HER in the long run. She's a moron not to realize that each negative farewell will likely lose her another vote. If you feel Gerry has been unfairly slighted, isn't it good he knows what Lisa is really like with concrete evidence, so that he won't vote for her in the end? |
Zuke8675309 | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:42 pm     I understood Lisa's comment to mean: "Gerry, I wish you were still in the house so that I could nominate you in the future." In other words, making a bit of a joke out of the whole thing. *shrug* I think Gerry, more than anyone, is mature enough not to take these things personally. |
Moondance | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:44 pm     I agree Zuke! |
Sia | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:45 pm     I don't remember any openly hostile or negative comments being included in the clips that outgoing hamsters have been shown upon eviction in any season of BB before tonight's show. I felt Lisa's comment to Gerry should have been edited out, too. It seems that in the past if a houseguest has had unkind things to say--and nothing positive to say--to the evicted hamster, the show simply didn't include that houseguest in the clip of farewell messages. Lisa didn't earn herself any points with Gerry or with any of the previously-evicted houseguests, either, with her comment. She would have been better off to have said nothing at all. She wishes she'd had the pleasure of putting up for nomination and eviction herself; isn't that the gist of her farewell-dig? I, too, wondered about Gerry's wife. Maybe she had to work and couldn't miss work to be there--or she needed to be home with the younger kids? I am confused, but I thought Gerry had two school-age kids at home. I might have missed the details on that, though. |
Starr_Wv | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 10:53 pm     Gerry told one of the HG one night that his wife has some type of back injury or some type of injury an cant sit for long periods of time that they cant travel or anything because of it so I would assume thats why she wasnt there to greet him tonight.. |
Abby | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 11:00 pm     Seems to me Lisa had the Chance to vote in her beloved Eric, I could have sworn I saw her vote AMY!! So what was the purpose of kicking the man when he is already down? :::Smirk::: The lady has class |
Draheid | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 11:11 pm     FWIW - The message from Lisa was very edited: [Jason's goodbye then cut to Lisa] [Front closeup] "What I really have to say to you" [Profile view ] "And what I really have to say to Eric" [Front closeup] "Is that I'm really sorry that I didn't have the pleasure of putting you up this week" [Cut to Marcellas]... Again, I have to wonder what was in between those three pieces of video. JMO - FWIW |
Moondance | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 11:16 pm     Thanks Draheid (MrInfo!) I agree... it was choppy and I would love to know what was in between... hard to judge if we don't have the full story! |
Allietex | Thursday, August 29, 2002 - 11:32 pm     I think Lisa was just trying to play to Eric. Someone made a comment in a post that this showed she was standing up for her man. Excuse me. Wasn't she the one who failed to vote for his return? It amazed me at the time they were nominated that Lisa complained that it wasn't fair that a couple was nominated. What? She thought they should be exempt because they teamed up. Boy in the next BB there would be nothing but couples if that was the case. They would all team up and expect not to be nominated. Now after all these weeks, she is talking about not having the pleasure of nominating Gerry. Why didn't she stay in the tub and win HOH the week Amy did. She could have nominated him that week. The whole thing is phony. If she had issues with him discuss it face to face don't wait and throw a brick at him as he is walking out the door. Honesty. Baloney! |
|