Rebuttal To: Defenders of Roddy Mancuso Unite Please
TV ClubHouse: Archive: Archive THREE :
Rebuttal To: Defenders of Roddy Mancuso Unite Please
Goddess146 | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 05:43 pm     The thread referenced is asking people to write Roddy and ask him to publicly deny that he attempted to influence to vote against Dani. The moderator has stated that no negative comments will be allowed in that thread. Since there are two sides to every story, I believe that Roddy's critics should have a chance to state their point of view about the subject. The subject being: The campaign to get Roddy to publicly deny the accusations. This thread should not be used an excuse to bash Mr. Mancuso. It should be used rebut the campaign to get his public denial. If this thread gets out of hand, I am sure the moderators will do their job. ==== My Rebuttal: Those of us who are critics of Roddy believe that Roddy has lied despite his denials. There is good and sufficient evidence to support the fact that he does and did lie. I feel that a public denial by Roddy would not be of value. If he has lied before, he can lie again. I would not believe a public denial from this man. I would believe statements by the other HGs saying that Roddy did nothing overtly or covertly to influence their vote. Note: If Roddy did influence the vote, I believe that he was perfectly within his rights to do so. There are no rules that say HGs can not or should not attempt to influence the final vote. I also believe that Dani is her own worse enemy. Dani did not need Roddy's help in losing to Lisa. |
Woodpecke® | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 05:56 pm     In spite of being moderated in a thread where the rules were not specified ahead of time, I will express my opinion that Roddy could not possibly have influenced a 9-1 vote against Danielle. The vote predicted by me before the show was 8-2, and I was far from alone in this assessment. That being said, I also feel no reason for Roddy to apologize to Danielle. This was a game, and her strategy proved to be a losing one. Roddy finished in sixth place; his influence has been analyzed to the point of total redundancy. |
Loppes | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:02 pm     Goddess146, *&^%#) dang it! sputter, sputter. Now how can I get mad at your folder, when you post such a hot picture of yourself in your profile. No fair! Lol. I'm going to have to find a picture of me to try draw the crowds. Okay, I'm back to the "other side". Lon |
Missy2 | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:03 pm     Wow this sounds like serious business heheh. The final show looked very edited and I wonder is that all Rod said to Dani? He seemed very bitter. I watched the entire season and aside of Dani's devil name calling I saw NOTHING wrong with her DR sessions. It was her bad mouthing in the house that was horrible but guess what? It was a game. Everyone in the house was no better or worse. I think Rod did campaign against Dani outside of the house but who knows. He sure did show himself to be a j3rk on BB3 Finale. It must have been very difficult for him to be in the house that long and pretend to be a nice guy. Maybe that was why he had to keep reminding us that he was a nice guy? And what's up with Lisa talking about how a good person should win and that everyone else felt the same way as her (why she won). I guess since she has appointed herself the OFFICIAL Self Proclaimed Princess of Darkness, now she can also deem who is a GOOD person (me me me me). The girl had the personality of <>. Oh well. heheh 007 |
Woodpecke® | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:10 pm     Amazing that a person posts a thread asking a player from a game show to publicly make a statement defending himself. If that isn't enough, this person comes into a thread that was created to refute this notion and makes light of the whole discussion with an unwarranted "wolf call". I think I have seen it all now. |
Foodbunny | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:15 pm     That's it. I can't take this board anymore. Goodbye. |
Wendo | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:26 pm     "This thread should not be used an excuse to bash Mr. Mancuso." Would certainly be nice if the other thread would follow the same guidelines with regard to Danielle. |
Woodpecke® | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:30 pm     Exactly, Wendo. |
Monalisa | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 06:53 pm     Should Roddy make a public statement? OH GAWD, PLEASE DON'T! He probably did do some campaigning (seems like his nature). Was it effective, possible, but I doubt it really made much of a difference. Actually, he would probably love being credited for it. If, and I say "if," he changed any votes, that is the fault of the voter for being so easily swayed. I don't think any of them were actually smart enough to follow Roddy's speaches. Most of them were just all googly eyed and nodding in agreement that he would even give them the time of day. I don't understand it, I wasn't impressed with him.....other than the way that he could manipulate people. But, was it him, or the group? Seems like Danielle, and maybe Lisa (not sure), were the only ones who weren't so easily swayed by his attentions. |
Loppes | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 07:00 pm     Wendo, Woodpecker, I'm sorry you didn't see it was actually a compliment to Goddess146. She has a very beautiful picture in her profile. lon |
Wendo | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 07:11 pm     Loppes, I didn't comment about your earlier post. |
Loppes | Friday, September 27, 2002 - 07:19 pm     Wendo, My apology. I wasn't concentrating. . Lon |
|