Dani -- The Most Trustworthy of The All?
TV ClubHouse: Archive: Archive ONE:
Dani -- The Most Trustworthy of The All?
Flyonthwall | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 04:07 pm     Dani just told Jason she gave her word to Lisa, but she lied and will break her word and take jason to the end with her, because they have an alliance. So her word is just as usless as any of the other HG. Therefor to answer the question in this thread... The most trustworth of them all? No She is exactly doing the same things. This makes her no more trust worthy than anyone else. If your Lisa she is untrustworthy. If your jason, she is trustwothy to him, although he knows she is not keeping her word to Lisa. Only Jason knows what he thinks about that. |
Wendo | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 04:12 pm     Woodpecke® said, "She choked and expects Jason to clean it up. He will as usual." Uh, well, Jason choked first. LOL! Woodpecke® said, "The reasons are long and detailed as to why Danielle cannot be called trustworthy in this game.' In your opinion, of course. There are also quite a few counterpoint opinions that state the opposite of your belief. |
Woodpecke® | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 04:19 pm     Yes. Jason choked. They both were up early while Lisa rested and was prepared and alert for the competition. Most if not all discussion about Danielle being trustworthy in this game is amusing to me. Others are free to think otherwise. I dismiss their opinions without facts. I also do not feel the need to put the initials IMO at the end of my posts. It is all opinion. |
Dogdoc | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 04:52 pm     Isn't she "as sly as a snake?" |
Showmemoney | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 04:55 pm     Yes, Dani is the most trustworthy. #1. He alliance to Jason from the beginning. #2. Her alliance to Lisa since the middle of the game. #3. The time she talked with Chiara about voting out Josh... she really wanted to get rid of Roddy, but she promised Chiara, and kept her word. #4. The time she talked to Amy about wanting to vote Roddy out, but Amy insisted it be Chiara. Now, Danielle voted against Roddy, but she did "guarantee" (in as much as she has the ability to guarantee anything in that house) at least 3 votes for Chiara. Ooops, may I be mixing up her talk with Chiara and Amy? Frankly, I forget. To defend her Marcellas "betrayal," she did catch wind of him lying to her on a couple different occasions, so is it so wrong to do the same back? |
Onlyhuman | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 05:04 pm     Actually, showmemoney, for #3 & #4 you are wrong. For #3, Danielle had every intention of voting out Roddy until Josh and Marcellas got in the huge fight and Danielle no longer had the votes to evict Roddy. Danielle couldn't be sure of Gerry's vote, Jason had refused to talk strategy, so Danielle, Lisa & Marcellas had initially planned to evict Roddy, 3-2. After the fight, Marcellas was determined to get rid of Josh so Danielle and Lisa gave in and did the same. For #4, Danielle had every intention of evicting Roddy from the minute he & Chiara were nominated, even though she had promised Amy the votes to evict Chiara (notice she NEVER said SHE would vote to evict Chiara, just that she had the votes.) Thoughout the week, the plan was to evict Roddy. Danielle even told Lisa what to say to Amy in order to get Amy to agree to evict Chiara, but Amy refused to budge. The night before the voting, they still planned to evict Roddy. When Marcellas told Amy, Amy went to Danielle and demanded that she keep her promise. So ultimately, she kept her promise to Amy only because Amy confronted her at the last minute and Danielle could not find a way around it without becoming a target. It can't possibly be considered trustworthy when you plan to break a promise from the moment you make it. |
K9lover1 | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 05:35 pm     Is Dani trustworthy? Only to the people she wants to be. This doesn't make her any better or worse then the others. I don't think you can play a game like this without some deception. However, outright lying is another thing and I feel that Dani lied to Lisa last night and if Lisa truly falls for it, and doesn't give it 100% on round 3 if it is against Dani, then that lie will have cost Lisa a lot!! Lisa may feel that if it's her and Dani in the end, it isn't necessary to win round 3 because of Dani's promise to her. I hope Lisa give the final competition everything she has. |
Wendo | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 05:56 pm     K9, outright lying IS allowed in this game as well. Along with deceit, back stabbing and double dealing. Why is lying different than deception in this game? If Lisa chooses to believe Dani's lie, well, that's Lisa's problem. Not Dani's. Anywaym, imo, Lisa will give it her all against whoever she's competing with. No reason to leave anything to chance. |
Cmore | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 06:40 pm     Wendo said "If Lisa chooses to believe Dani's lie, well, that's Lisa's problem. Not Dani's." Quite true and for those of you who choose to think Dani is trustworthy, well thats your problem, not ours. |
K9lover1 | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 07:06 pm     Wendo - I do agree that lying is allowed. Deception was probably not the right word. What I mean is that IMO someone misleading another person vs. stating a falsehood in black and white are two different things. If Lisa asks Dani "are you in an alliance with Jason" and she dodges the answer or tries to point her in a different direction, that is different than saying "no" and lying. So, is Dani trustworthy? IMO where Jason is concerned...yes, where Marcellas, Lisa are concerned ..no. If Lisa believes her, it's Lisa's fault - I realize that but hope it doesn't happen. Who knows Lisa might not even make it to the final two. |
Woodpecke® | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 07:12 pm     LOL @ Cmore. Great comeback! |
Cindyluvsroddy | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 07:22 pm     well, i think we clearly established that Dani is NOT the most trustworthy HG ... |
Cindyluvsroddy | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 07:26 pm     hey woodpeck! where is my rum and coke? |
Twiggyish | Friday, September 20, 2002 - 07:27 pm     Yup, I agree Cindy. However, there will be a ton more posts saying otherwise..LOL |
Showmemoney | Saturday, September 21, 2002 - 08:34 am     When I posted why I thought Dani was trustworthy, I had no idea it meant you were allowed to tell me I was wrong for thinking she is. "It can't possibly be considered trustworthy when you plan to break a promise from the moment you make it." Don't tell me what I think trustworthy is or ISN'T. I gave my opinion. I thought that was what this thread is for. |
Wiseolowl | Saturday, September 21, 2002 - 08:40 am     May I quote that eminent philosopher Mr. Jerome Howard.. aka "Curly" of the Three Stooges : "If you don't succeed at first..keep on sucking 'till you do succeed" Na Na Na. |
Missy2 | Saturday, September 21, 2002 - 08:41 am     What555456, your original post was GREAT and I completely agree with you, its too bad the evicted hgs won't see it this way, Dani probably will not win because of her behavior when the truth is that she deserves the money and has played the game the BEST. (IMHO). By the way, I only read What555456 original post. |
Onlyhuman | Saturday, September 21, 2002 - 09:09 am     Showmemoney, I apologize for not phrasing my response more appropriately. Reading it over, I realize that it sounded like I meant your opinion was wrong when I was actually trying to point out the fact that some of the "facts" that you based your opinion on were incorrect. In your post, you indicated that you were a little confused about the events and I was trying to flesh them out. And I should have said, IMO, it is difficult to consider someone trustworthy if they have every intention of breaking a promise the minute they make it, but circumstances force them to keep it. We are all expressing our opinions here, and I would NEVER intentionally try to make it seem like you are not entitled to yours. I apologize again if it appeared like I was doing so. |
Showmemoney | Saturday, September 21, 2002 - 10:08 am     Onlyhuman, aaah, now I understand what you meant. No problem. Thanks for clearing it up. Sorry if I sounded so defensive. Life is good.  |
Woodpecke® | Sunday, September 22, 2002 - 05:18 pm     Captain Morgan and Coke for Cindyluvsroddy coming right up!!!!!!!!!!!! |
Bridgetlovesbb | Sunday, September 22, 2002 - 06:04 pm     Hey wood, pass one over here! I will join Cindyluvsroddy in having a drink of that! =0) |
|